A Moment in the Sun

If Goldman Sachs is publicly bullish on gold, is that a good thing or bad thing for gold bulls?

Wall Street’s notorious trading house published a report on gold earlier this week setting a price target of US$1,300 in the next six months. The report cited several factors. But before we get into them, we’ll confess it made us a bit nervous. Whenever any broker is saying one thing, you have to wonder if they’re actually doing the opposite.

That said, Goldman did make a point that is true of an asset in a bull market: it requires corrections to shake out the speculators and weak hands from time to time. Following the June high north of $1,250 the net speculative long positions declined. Traders took profits. And so did momentum players in the exchange traded funds market.

But then something happened that Michael Pascoe and Rory Robertson did not expect. The gold bubble did not pop. Because it’s not a bubble. The momentum players departed and the price found plenty of support. It’s now around US$1,220.

Goldman says the big catalyst for move higher (other than its announcement leading to a stampede of money into gold short-term) is a repricing of U.S. growth expectations for the rest of this year and all of next. Maybe it’s a fear trade, or just bearishness on U.S. corporate profits when unemployment keeps rising.

Either way, about the only dubious chart we saw in the whole report is the one showing lower U.S. real interest rates and the gold price (exhibit five). As those cool cats in statistics say, correlation is not causation. Its possible low rates give speculators fuel to play in the gold market. But it’s more likely, we reckon, that U.S. rates are low because the bond market is pricing in a deflationary scenario.

So why would gold rise in a deflationary scenario? Good question! It brings us full circle to the argument fund – manager David Einhorn made when we announced his gold position: you buy gold when you think monetary and fiscal policy are bad (we’re paraphrasing). Whether it’s inflation or deflation matters less than something unconventional and bad is going down. Gold does well in that environment, what with it being real money and all.

Take a look at the Aussie gold price chart below. It shows you that gold is much closer to making a new high in U.S. dollar terms than it is in Aussie dollar terms. For Aussie gold to match the greenback gain, you’d need a much stronger greenback or a much weaker Aussie. It’s worth noting that following the Fed’s announcement that it would sort of begin quantitative easing part two, the Aussie made the second-largest declines against the greenback, trailing only the dreaded Esperanto currency (the euro).

1 Year Spot Gold in Australian Dollars vs US Dollars

As we have banged on about gold for years now – and have a long position in the list of recommendations to Australian Wealth Gameplan readers – we won’t test your patience much longer. But yesterday’s news that the Aussie unemployment went rate up in July wouldn’t be Aussie dollar bullish, would it?

Maybe the Aussie will get a boost when this miserable Federal election nonsense is over. When thinking about the election we recall the phrase, “Don’t vote! It only encourages them.” Of course voting in Australia is compulsory. But it might be a fine worth copping if you can say you weren’t an accessory to, “the advanced auction of stolen goods,” as Mark Twain once put it.

Seriously. If anything is clear so far about the difference between the two major parties, it’s that both treat Australians as chattel. We are but tax slaves who exist to fund the government’s spending pleasures. And the Greens? More like the Reds!

But that’s all politics. Financial independence is the only real defence against this kind of relentless State encroachment from all sides. Get it. Keep it. Defend it.

Whether you like it or not, more and more governments across the world are spending out of an empty pocket. They’re spending to give people money that’ve lost jobs as a result of the structural shift in the labour markets. That shift came from globalisation. The money might keep people above water for awhile, but it’s no replacement for a real job making real things.

More and more spending is going to simply pay the interest on previously borrowed money. This is probably the most dangerous aspect of a credit bubble. You borrow and spend all that money and, and the end of the day, you have nothing to show for it…no bridges…no roads…no factories…no real increase in the capital stock. Just a lot of over-priced residential housing that suddenly isn’t in such short supply as you thought.

And now Australia finds itself at an interesting crossroads. Just a little debt didn’t seem like such a bad idea at the height of the GFC. Both parties now promise to pay it off quickly, with all the bounty from mineral and energy royalties. Both will increase spending too, but in different places, cutting other spending priorities.

But should the housing bubble pop sooner rather than later, and should Aussie banks find themselves last in the queue for global capital in another phase of the Great Correction, the temptation for more government borrowing will be nigh irresistible. Why?

Well, our stance against government debt may seem dogmatic. But if it is, it’s because the modern State always abuses the power to borrow. Always.

Whether it’s to fund politically popular but economically unproductive projects, or whether it’ just a way of putting off tough choices about actually reducing government spending and, thus, the reach of the State into private life, it’s always easier to borrow and kick the can down the road.

Debt is the health of the State in the same way that liquor is the health of the alcoholic. The relationship is inherently destructive. But we reckon that in the face of so much unproductive debt (household and sovereign) the only politically palatable policy response will be to monetise that debt: pay it off or buy it from bank with new money. The deflationists can enjoy their moment in the sun while it lasts. But it won’t last for long at this rate.

Dan Denning
for Markets and Money

Dan Denning
Dan Denning examines the geopolitical and economic events that can affect your investments domestically. He raises the questions you need to answer, in order to survive financially in these turbulent times.

Leave a Reply

6 Comments on "A Moment in the Sun"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Sorry to have to correct you with this irrelevancy, but it was that great libertarian H.L. Mencken who said that elections are an advanced auction of stolen goods, not Mark Twain. “All government is, in its essence, organized exploitation, and in virtually all of its existing forms it is the implacable enemy of every industrious and well-disposed man.” “Every election is a sort of advance auction of stolen goods.” “The storm center of lawlessness in every American State is the State Capitol. It is there that the worst crimes are committed; it is there that lawbreaking attains to the estate… Read more »

The great Menchken, he’d be having a field day if he were still alive.


Debt is the currency of the whole world just about. I say we live not in capatalism there is no capital, just a debt and bond system, that is fuedalism. I despise this system, but i have no power with a vote, I have a family and will try my best to put them first. But as Voltaire said “lucky is the man who is neither hammer nor anvil in this world”

Ned S

“I have a family and will try my best to put them first” – Think you’ve summed it up for a lot of us anyway Nic.

Don’t know much about Voltaire – I wonder if his philosophy said anything about the red hot bit of iron in the middle getting whacked?


“…in capatAlism there is no capital…”

Well, you got _thAt_ one right, son.

Can’t blame the schools. A highly-educated man who quotes Voltaire from memory has no excuse… .

Isle of Man Gold Angel
Isle of Man Gold Angel

“Deficit spending is simply a scheme for the ‘hidden’ confiscation of wealth. Gold stands in the way of this insidious process. It stands as a protector of property rights.” – Alan Greenspan

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to letters@marketsandmoney.com.au