Asian Markets Have Been Hit Hard By The Subprime Crisis

Bottoms…bottoms…and more bottoms…

Today, we have to open our collar and loosen our tie; we see more bottoms than at the Folies Bergeres.

“What do you call it when the stock of the country’s fifth-largest investment bank trades at $50 on a Thursday and at $3 the following Monday?” asks Jim Cramer. “I call it a bottom.”

Of course, everyone says he saw the bottom in the U.S. stock market in January…and the bottom in the financials when Bear Stearns owners panicked and agreed to sell the firm for $2 a share…subsequently amended upwards.

And look at the U.S. builders – they seem to have bottomed out too. “It can’t get worse than this,” say industry spokesmen. The index has now turned up.

Meanwhile, look at the Chinese stock market. As predicted in this space – remember, lines of people in Shanghai waiting to open up brokerage accounts? Thousands of new accounts being opened every day? Share prices up 500% in two years? Now, the Chinese stock market has collapsed. The FXI – a kind of Dow Jones Industrial average for the Shanghai market – fell from 220 to 120, a loss of 45%.

It wasn’t the only one. Both Japan and India fell 31%. And Vietnam must have felt as though it had been hit by another Tet Offensive – stocks are down 53% since October. (Colleague Manraaj Singh swears this is a buying opportunity for the Vietnam Fund…more about that some other time.)

But now…all these markets seem to be going back up. Have we seen the bottoms?

And what’s this – gold, our favorite metal went down to $887 or thereabouts, then bounced back over $900. And yesterday, gold added another $9. Have we seen the bottom in the gold market correction too? A lot of people are betting on it…

Look around you; you’ll see bottoms everywhere. Yesterday, prices on just about everything were rebounding. The euro rebounded against the dollar. Asian markets rose. Wheat, soy, rice prices – all on the way back up. The CRB index rose too.

(Even base metals have gotten so precious that a front page report in today’s International Herald Tribune tells us that thieves are stripping the lead off of church roofs in the UK.)

About the only thing that didn’t bounce yesterday was oil – which was off a bit, but still holding over $100. Yes, dear reader, it looks to us as if oil found its bottom at around $100, which is a remarkable thing.

Even in volatility, it looks like a kind of bottom has been found – meaning, volatility is decreasing…markets are calming. As they say on Wall Street…the bottoms are in…

…or are they?

George Soros wonders:

“We had a good bottom,” Soros said yesterday in an interview in New York, referring to the rally in stocks and the dollar after JP Morgan Chase & Co. agreed to buy Bear Stearns Cos. on March 17. “This will probably not prove to be the final bottom,” he said, adding the rebound may last six weeks to three months as the U.S. moves closer to a recession.

*** Soros had a new book released online yesterday: The New Paradigm for Financial Markets (Public Affairs, 2008). He explains the causes of the current meltdown, which he traces to the big turnaround in 1980…when U.S. President Ronald Reagan and U.K. Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher came to power and borrowing ballooned.

Hmmm…sounds familiar. That is what we have been saying too – that people got the wrong idea about the free market. They thought it was a panacea. As long as you reduced taxes and regulation, they believed, you could get away with murder…or at least leverage.

Not so. Capitalism is not a system that makes people rich. It’s a moral system…not really a financial system at all. And like any moral system, it’s fuzzy at the edges and difficult to master. Where does the Atlantic stop and the Jersey shore begin? No one can tell you exactly. And no one can tell you where, exactly, one person’s rights begin and another’s stop. Does a landowner really have an unencumbered right to enjoy the usufructs of his property…knowing that his ancestor stole the land, even fair and square, from the local natives? Does an airline have the right to fly its jumbo jets into an airport…regardless of the noise pollution it causes to the local householders? Would motorists have the right to drive gas-guzzlers if the planet really were headed for a global climatic disaster? Who knows? All you can do is do your best…trying to respect other peoples’ property…and other peoples’ freedom to do what they want…and trying to hold people to their agreements and obligations. Some people get rich; some people get poor. Some people lose; some win. But mostly, grosso modo, the free market gives people what they’ve got coming.

*** While George Soros believes the advanced markets of the West will begin heading down again in a few months, he thinks that some emerging markets will continue going up. He’s heavily invested in India, for example, where he believes “the fundamentals remain good.”

In other words, capitalism still works. But the winners in this capitalistic world are not necessarily those who blather on about freedom and market economies.

Soro’s former sidekick, and our old friend, Jim Rogers, says he wouldn’t put a dime in India. He sold all his emerging markets, except China. The Middle Kingdom has very little political freedom. According to the theorists of the Reagan/Thatcher era…China as it is today couldn’t exist. Political freedom was thought to be inseparable from economic freedom. And economic freedom was considered essential to growth and prosperity. But there it is – China! What to make of it?

Jim is so sure that China will be the world’s next super-power, perhaps replacing America as the leading hegemon of the planet, that he has insisted that his daughter learn to speak Mandarin. Practically from the day she was born she’s had a Chinese nanny.

So colleague Manraaj Singh is good company. He has faith in the emerging markets too. His favorite Asian market is Vietnam, also a communist country…the one that booted out U.S. troops 40 years ago and imprisoned America’s candidate for president, John McCain.

But yesterday, Manraaj was not talking about Vietnam. Instead, he had this to say about U.S. Treasury Secretary Paulson’s visit to China:

“In a press conference in Beijing, he said that he emphasised to the Chinese government the benefits of more efficient capital markets as a device that could ensure ordinary citizens received an “adequate” return on their savings…and that’s when I burst out laughing!

“Since the beginning of the decade, the S&P 500 Index has actually fallen by five percent. In China, the benchmark Shanghai A-shares Index is up by 124 per cent – and that’s after falling 43 per cent from its peak in October. They were up 296 per cent at their peak. I think that Chinese investors have seen an “adequate” return on their savings. U.S. investors, on the other hand, probably wouldn’t think so…and neither would the average British investor… the FTSE is down 11 per cent over the same period.”

Interestingly, Asian markets have been hit hard… not by anything they did wrong, but by the sub-prime crisis, which was 100% made in America. The emerging markets have their troubles and weaknesses, Manraaj concedes, but they are fundamentally in better positions than the US, because they have less debt and cheaper operating costs.

Bill Bonner
Markets and Money

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America’s most respected authorities. Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind Markets and Money.
Bill Bonner

Latest posts by Bill Bonner (see all)

Leave a Reply

2 Comments on "Asian Markets Have Been Hit Hard By The Subprime Crisis"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted

It seems to me that a dictatorship (China) actually has more potential for economic growth, as they are not susceptible to “mob rule”, which usually results in socialistic policies… Of course, you can end up in a police-state communism as well, depending on the dictator…

Smack MacDougal
Bill “Dear Reader” Bonner says, “But mostly, grosso modo, the free market gives people what they’ve got coming.” All should run for the hills when you hear or read someone write, “the free market”. No monolithic one market exist. Yet, many markets exist, although calling them “Free Markets” would be a stretch. No worthy advice can come from anyone who thinks that capitalism means “the free market” or that a monolithic “the free market” exists. Folks don’t get what they have coming to them. Nearly all Everday folks become indoctrinated shortly after birth into the many Statist rhetorical schemes filled… Read more »
Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to