Brazil: The Next United States of America

What brings us to Brazil?

Well, it’s the country of the future. It’s the ‘New America’. It’s where it is all happening. Growth. Innovation. And wealth accumulation.

That’s what our old friend Jim Davidson says. He’s got a new book out on the subject: Brazil is the New America.

Is it really the ‘new America’? We don’t know. But it sure has a lot going for it that the old America would like to have.

Like less debt, rising wages and real growth – not the gimmicked-up, debt-fuelled growth we have in the US. In Brazil, households are actually getting richer.

Speaking of which, the Fed’s ‘all you can eat’ QE deal is starting to look like a big flop. Remember, the idea is to get the stock market jazzed up before the election. That way, Obama will keep his job… and Bernanke can continue his high school-level monetary experiments. What happens when you add an infinite amount of new money to an economy? We’re going to find out!

Well, the latest QE is a flop because it’s not doing much for the stock market. On Friday… just a week after the announcement…stocks went down. The big surge hasn’t happened.

But Bernanke’s goal is probably much more modest. His man Barack has a big advantage – the Republican candidate. Obama is not running a great campaign. He’s a terrible president. And after eight-plus percent unemployment, he should be a pushover.

But Mitt Romney is doing all he can to help him stay in office. With Mitt’s help, all Ben has to do is to keep stocks from collapsing and the Obama team will almost certainly get another four years.

Whether or not Bernanke will be able to hold stocks up, we don’t know. But we wouldn’t want to put money on it either way. It’s pure gambling at this stage. And we don’t like to bet… unless the fix is in. Actually, in this case, the fix is in. But these fixes have a way of coming unfixed as soon as you begin to depend on them.

So let’s go back to Brazil. Jim Davidson:

“… it reminds me more of the America I knew as a young man. Brazil’s current population of 203 million (as of July 2011), is roughly that of the United States in 1969.

“Brazil has accounted for more of the world’s real economic growth since Lehman went broke than any other country except China.

“Not only has Brazil been growing at a significant clip in recent years, while the US economy flat lines, but Brazil seems to have much more scope for growth in the future.

“Thirty-five years ago, Brazil was importing food. Today, it is the world’s largest exporter of five major crops, and it’s also a major exporter of beef and chicken. Brazilian scientists have engineered new, short-cycle tropical versions of temperate crops like soybeans and corn.

These mature eight to 12 weeks faster than the original temperate versions, making it possible for Brazilian farmers to produce two crops a year rather. By 2002, the overall average yield for soybeans in Brazil (2.6 tons/hectare) surpassed the average yield in the United States (2.4 tons/hectare). More significantly, the cost of producing soybeans in Brazil fell to about $6.23 per 60 kg bag, just half of the US level of $11.72.

“With a population just two-thirds the size of the US, Brazil has created over 15 million jobs over the past eight years while the US lost untold millions of jobs. (An exact comparison is rendered difficult by the shameful fact that US employment data are grossly exaggerated and undependable.)

“Combining energy independence and vast natural resources, including 60 percent of the world’s unused arable land, Brazil is the world’s first tropical superpower, offering a whole new frontier of growth.

“But don’t make the mistake of thinking that Brazil is just a large, well-watered farm. Brazil has a diversified modern economy. In fact, agriculture represents only 5.5 percent of the Brazilian economy.

“Brazil also has a large mining sector, but 84 percent of Brazil’s exports are manufactured products, beginning with automobiles and airplanes (Brazil is the world’s third leading producer of commercial aircraft). Steel, machine tools, textiles and apparel, cement, chemicals, fertilizer, footwear, rail cars and locomotives are also important Brazilian exports.

“The real median wage in the United States has been worse than stagnant for a quarter of a century, and one in every seven Americans now participates in the food stamp program, reflecting a disturbing growth of poverty. As reported on September 12 by the Census Bureau in Income, Poverty, and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2011, real median household income in the United States has declined for the fourth year running. It is now lower than it was in 1995.

“Even more startling, when the current, grossly defective, CPI-U (all urban consumers) price index is used to deflate median household income, it is lower than it was in 1969. But this actually overestimates the stability of median household income in the US. Over the years, the methodology for calculating inflation has been consciously altered to disguise and understate it, which thereby overstates real GDP growth and per capita real income.

“As John Williams, of Shadow Government Statistics, points out: ‘The headline August CPI-U rose by 0.6 percent, versus a 0.05 percent increase (unchanged rounded to one decimal point) in July. In August 2012 unadjusted year-to-year CPI-U inflation increased to 1.69 percent from 1.41 percent in July… Adjusted to pre-Clinton (1990) method methodology, annual SGS-alternative CPI inflation was roughly 5.2 percent in August 2012, versus 4.9 percent in July, while the 1980-based measure was about 9.3 percent in August versus 9 percent in July.

“The implication of the Census Bureau report on income and poverty is that all the expected income gains for the working lifetimes of Baby Boomers have been washed away in a torrent of red ink. Meanwhile, almost 40 million Brazilians rose out of poverty into the middle class in the last decade.”

If Brazil is the new America, as Davidson says, what happens to the old one? Simple, America is the new Brazil.

Davidson explains:

“The good thing about Brazil is that the country suffered even higher and more impoverishing inflation over the last half century than the United States. Economists from Brazil’s largest private bank, Bradesco, assert that the accumulated inflation in Brazil between 1961 and 2006 was 14.2 quadrillion percent.

“Indeed, decades of hyperinflation provided Brazilians with a valuable education that residents of the US living with a more gradual and tolerable inflation missed. Runaway inflation taught Brazilians that financial crises were not just theoretical possibilities or footnotes from the distant past, but vivid realities.

“They also learned that chronic deficit spending and quantitative easing are recipes for economic disaster. Through the strong leadership of then-finance minister, and later the 34th president of Brazil, Fernando Henrique Cardoso, Brazil successfully implemented radical reforms to curtail deficits and outlaw their deficit financing by the banking system.

“Cardozo and Franco ‘also criminalized a major source of inflation,’ and ‘threatened bank officials with jail if they lent money to the government.’ Do you think the executives of big banks who are members of the Fed’s primary dealer system would go along with the gag and finance Obama’s deficits if by doing so they faced arrest and the possibility of long prison terms? I don’t. And that is one reason I think Brazil’s economy has a brighter future than that of the United States, where the introduction of QE 3 is the latest and least mistakable prelude to hyperinflation.”


Bill Bonner
for Markets and Money

From the Archives…

The Sharks Amongst the School
21-09-2012 – Greg Canavan

Bernankonomics 101
20-09-2012 – Greg Canavan

There’s Going To Be a Fight
19-09-2012 – Dan Denning

The World’s #1 Money Printer
18-09-2012 – Bill Bonner

The Video That Started All the Controversy
17-09-2012 – Dan Denning

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Best-selling investment author Bill Bonner is the founder and president of Agora Publishing, one of the world's most successful consumer newsletter companies. Owner of both Fleet Street Publications and MoneyWeek magazine in the UK, he is also author of the free daily e-mail Markets and Money.
Bill Bonner

Latest posts by Bill Bonner (see all)

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Notify of
Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to