Does the Stock Market Know Something We Don’t?

Does the stock market know something we don’t? Yesterday, investors bid up prices on the Dow stocks to a new high. The index rose 115 points.

According to theory, the markets know more than any single investor, analyst or economist. In theory, the markets know everything there is to know. In theory, the markets are always right.

But what the heck? This is the same stock market that signaled clear sailing ahead ten years ago. Soon after, equities hit an iceberg. They sank for the next decade.

Here at Markets and Money, we had our own views. At the beginning of the ’00s, we told readers to sell their stocks. We were right. The stock market was wrong. Heh heh.

So, who ya gonna trust now? The stock market… Or, Markets and Money?

Who knows… Maybe we’re wrong this time, but we see another 10 years of trouble coming. Two years ago, the credit cycle peaked out. After half a century of adding debt, the private sector had had enough. Borrowing turned down. Last November, it registered its 10th month in a row of declines, something that had never happened since they began keeping records after WWII.

Consumer spending has held up surprisingly well. But with credit contracting and unemployment high and rising, it can’t continue.

Small businesses create jobs. But who wants to take the risk of funding a small business now? Not the banks. And the capital markets are closed off to small businesses. You have to have a big business – preferably one that is dying… Then, you can get all the money you want from Wall Street and the feds.

Since the downturn began two years ago, 7.5 million jobs have been lost. There is no sign that they will be found anytime soon. Jobless people do not spend a lot of money. Ergo, you can’t really expect an economic surge until people get jobs.

When will that happen? Possibly years from now…maybe 2…maybe 5…maybe 10…

Yes, dear reader, we are in a depression. It is a period of adjustment…of correction…of de-leveraging…of paying down debt. And there’s not much the feds can do about it – except disguise it…delay it…and make it worse.

The government can spend money. The government can inflate the currency. But it’s neither government spending nor inflation of the currency that makes an economy healthy. If inflating the currency could make an economy prosper, where did Zimbabwe go wrong? And if government spending could boost an economy, what did Cuba do wrong? Or Venezuela? The two-bit, banana republic economies are almost all burdened by too much government stimulus. The feds tax too much, spend too much, borrow too much and inflate too much. Instead of doing their jobs – enforcing property rights, protecting people from crime, and staying out of the way – they meddle and spend. The president gets a fancy house and lots of security guards. And the economy rots.

Of course, we could be wrong about what is happening in the US. But our guess is that the stock market is wrong instead. Stock market investors anticipate a return to ‘normal.’ But the normal they’re looking at is a very unusual credit bubble that blew up and can’t be mended. The real normal is what we’re getting. And the real normal is a world where bad stuff happens. Investors make mistakes. Markets make mistakes. Often, they are misled by their own financial authorities, such as Ben Bernanke. The US Fed chief meddles in the economy and distorts the picture. Investors look, but get the wrong idea.

Our guess is that stock market investors are seeing the distorted picture caused by the feds’ meddling…not the real picture. They look. They see low interest rates. They see stimulus. They see a stock market that seemed so friendly and so rewarding for so long that they can’t imagine anything else. They see a government taking action…and making things better. They read Thomas Friedman and think the ‘political class’ can fix whatever problems it encounters.

But in the real world, the political class is a life-threatening parasite. Allow it to grow large enough and the host – the private economy – will shrivel up and die.

And in the real normal world, markets go up…and then they go down. We are in one of those periods of decline. We are in a depression, with a growing, parasitic political class. This phase won’t end any time soon.


Gary Shilling is probably right. He says to buy Treasury bonds and the dollar. They’re both probably going up this year.

Why? Because we are in a depression. And when investors finally realize it they will seek safety. They will buy US Treasury bonds, raising prices and lowering yields. Those Treasury bonds are in dollars, by the way. Investors will want dollars.

There are two main emotions that drive investors – fear and greed. Lately, greed drives them to buy emerging markets, stocks generally, and commodities. Fear drives them to dump all their risky investments and head for cover. They believe cover is found in the dollar and in US Treasury bonds – traditionally, the world’s safest credits.


“Ireland has changed so much,” said a colleague at last night’s dinner. He was speaking early in the evening. Later, we went to Henry Downs’ place…where the #9 whisky is as smooth as a baby’s derriere. We can’t remember what happened after that.

“The Irish had big families. Everyone had five or six children. We were a big exporter of people. People were our major export. And of course, the world is full of mics and paddies. America, Canada, Australia, New Zealand…but there are also a lot of Irish in Argentina.

“Birth control was illegal. I remember when I was 16…I had a friend who wanted to sleep with his girlfriend. Since I was tall and looked older he asked me to go into a pharmacy and buy condoms. It was so awkward. I waited until there were no other customers in the shop. Then, I went in….trying to make my voice lower than it really was…and asked the middle aged woman behind the counter for condoms. It was so embarrassing. It’s a wonder people had sex at all.”

“People in Ireland are still funny about sex,” said another Irish colleague. “My boyfriend and I ‘lived in sin’ before we got married. Everybody knew it. But ‘living in sin’ was not just a joke. People thought it was a real sin. They didn’t really mind it, but they expected us to pretend we weren’t sinning. So when my parents would visit we had to pretend we had separate bedrooms…even though it was obvious we were sleeping together.

“But nowadays, it’s different. Now couples only have one or two children.”


Bill Bonner
for Markets and Money

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America’s most respected authorities. Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind Markets and Money.
Bill Bonner

Latest posts by Bill Bonner (see all)

Leave a Reply

1 Comment on "Does the Stock Market Know Something We Don’t?"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
A crazy thought: Imagine a world where you, and all your relatives didn’t have to do a day’s work, forever. Everybody else comes and does it for you – servants, maids, cleaners, repairers, drivers, cooks, everything. Imagine walking around with a wallet full of money that never runs out. It basically doesn’t happen in the first world now, except to a very small number of extremely rich people. Chances are, some of their relatives have to work for a living … terrible isn’t it? There are just not enough people around to do the maid-work etc. Money has lost its… Read more »
Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to