Don't Bet on Saudi America

The US is the place to be. That’s what everybody says. America has all the advantages: the strong US economy, a younger population, cheaper energy, and a central bank more ready to print money as necessary.

Look for US manufacturing to get a boost, especially in industries such as chemicals, from new energy discoveries. Households should benefit from lower energy prices too. And the dollar should go up as foreigners move their money to America in search of safety and higher returns.

Here’s Business Insider:

‘We are seeing calls that, thanks to shale drilling, the US is poised to become the world leader in oil production, leading some to begin invoking ‘Saudi America’

‘…Goldman Sachs analyst Kamakshya Trivedi, weighed in on the global macro implications of this phenomenon in a note titled: The shale revolution is changing the global energy landscape.

‘The note actually goes further, talking about how the entire economic landscape could potentially change.

‘The main impact, they write, is that oil prices will no longer prove a brake on growth:

‘”… shifts in production are gradually loosening the oil price constraint that has been a persistent feature of the global economy. If global demand growth can recover, the risks that it will be choked off by rising oil prices are receding.”

‘This will produce a knock-on effect for household incomes in the West, while blindsiding petro-states:

‘”The drag on household incomes in the developed world from this source should end.”

‘Meanwhile, central banks will be able to shift their focus from containing headline inflation:

‘”Rising energy prices have affected core inflation measures to a degree, influencing the inflation outlook even for central banks, like the Federal Reserve, that have focused more on underlying inflation measures. As a result, lower ongoing energy inflation means that monetary policy may be easier on average than it otherwise would have been.”‘

What? Fighting inflation? What central bank is worried about fighting inflation? They’ve got ZIRP and QE… they seem to be trying to cause inflation, not fight it. These guys aren’t firefighters, trying to put out the flames of inflation. No, they’re pyromaniacs. As Tony Boechk puts it:

‘The magnitude of reflation efforts is without precedent.’

Meanwhile, here’s Philip Stephens, writing in the Financial Times:

‘America’s military reach will be unrivalled for decades. It has a stable political system. The country’s demographic profile is significantly better than that of any potential rivals… The US has huge advantage in technological prowess and intellectual resources…’

It’s time to buy America.

How about that, dear reader? Is it time to buy America?

Maybe not. The real effect of cheaper energy, in the US, will be to allow policymakers to make a bigger mess of things. They’ll shift more of America’s real wealth to the zombies. They’ll go deeper into debt. They’ll print more money.

The US got lucky. Its energy entrepreneurs found ways to squeeze oil and gas out of stone. Pretty nice trick. But sometimes good luck is the worst kind of luck. Atlanta would have been better off if the South had lost the war before Sherman approached…

…George A Custer would have been better off if he’d gotten fired before taking his troops to the Little Big Horn… and the whole world would have been better off if Gavrilo Princip had not had the good luck to have a revolver in his hand when he accidentally ran into the Archduke Ferdinand.

Putting that aside, one thing we notice immediately: Mr Stephens seems to have no idea how markets work. Reading his description of America’s pluses, it looks like a time to sell the country, not buy it.

He says the US economy is leading in several important ways. But so what? What America is today must already be reflected in the prices of her stocks, bonds and real estate. Today determines current prices; future prices are tomorrow’s business.

If the US economy could surprise on the upside, it might be a good time to buy. If the surprise is more likely to come on the downside, it is better to sell.

It is like betting at a race track. The previous winner may hold his head high and prance around. He may be the favourite to win again. He may be at the very peak of his career. But that is not usually a good time to bet on him.

Investors tend to over-value the recent past and forget the distant past. They like betting on yesterday’s winners. They run the odds up on the favourite until the payout for winning is small and the risk of loss is huge.

That is why the ten-year note yields so little – less than 1.6% last week. And that is why US stocks are so expensive – well above average on a P/E basis. Stocks and bonds have been in bull markets for the last 30 years.

A whole generation of investors has grown up with no experience of anything else. As far as they know, stocks only go up. And on the rare occasions when they go down, the feds come in to push them back up again.

As for bonds, they’re a one-way bet too. Ben Bernanke has pledged to keep bond prices high for years into the future. If prices begin to fall (pushing up bond yields) he’ll come into the market to shore them up.

Of course, it’s been many years since we thought we could predict the future. A full head of hair and soothsaying both went away at about the same time. What we try to do now is to wait for things to get so far out of whack that even a Fed governor has to work hard not to notice. Then, we bet that they will get back into whack.

When? How? We don’t know. But right now, we see US debt at levels that look out of whack to us. The feds are running real, unfunded deficits equal to 21 times GDP increases.

Where this will lead, we don’t know. But probably not to higher prices for US stocks and bonds.


Bill Bonner

for Markets and Money

From the Archives…

Will Lower Interest Rates Impact Australia in 2013?
7-12-2012 – Greg Canavan

Is the Australian Economy in Recession?
6-12-2012 – Greg Canavan

US Debt: Why America May Need a Bail Out by the IMF
5-12-2012 – Bill Bonner

If Profits are Falling Why are Stocks Rising?
4-12-2012 – Dan Denning

The Frontier Way
3-12-2012 – Dan Denning

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Best-selling investment author Bill Bonner is the founder and president of Agora Publishing, one of the world's most successful consumer newsletter companies. Owner of both Fleet Street Publications and MoneyWeek magazine in the UK, he is also author of the free daily e-mail Markets and Money.
Bill Bonner

Latest posts by Bill Bonner (see all)

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Notify of
Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to