The Greatest Mystery of the 21st Century

We took the train from Paris to London…and then from London to the village of Templecombe in Somerset.

We came to visit a friend.

This was the home of Lord Uxbridge,’ our host pointed to an estate as we drove by.

Severed leg

The cavalry commander was with Wellington at Waterloo and now is regarded as a model of English sangfroid.

After leading several charges against French infantry, Lord Uxbridge’s leg was shattered by cannon shot.

He reportedly turned to Wellington, who was nearby, and said, ‘By God, sir, I’ve lost my leg.’

‘By God, sir, yes you have,’ replied the Iron Duke.

The severed leg was a tourist attraction in Belgium, where it was buried.

I tell my neighbours that I like President Trump,’ continued our host.

You’d think it was the Battle of Waterloo all over. They go ballistic. They can’t believe it.

I just say that to shake them up. I don’t really know if I like Trump or not. He’s very American. Hard for us to understand.

But I’m so fed up with the government here. They’re all socialists, even the Conservatives. All they want is my money. They act as if it were theirs. And they don’t even say thank you.

Strange initiative

Our friend has a large farm. But in order to leave it to his children intact, he needs cash to pay the taxes.

And cash can be hard for farmers to come by. He may have to sell part of the estate to pay the death duties.

Taxes have been our subject for the last few days. There is a proposal on the table from Team Trump (most likely already dead) to cut taxes in the US.

It is a strange initiative, pitched as a ‘miracle for the middle class’. But it will do little for average taxpayers; many would see their taxes go up as a result of the plan.

We recall the Reagan boom, such as it was. It began with a tax cut, largely financed with more debt.

During his two terms, President Reagan increased government spending and ballooned the national debt.

The deficit was 1.6% of GDP in 1979. When Reagan finished his last term, in 1989, it had risen to almost 5% of GDP.

How was it possible, we asked yesterday, that this spending boom did not cause inflation to go up?

Greenspan’s conundrum

It was a ‘conundrum’ to former Fed chief Alan Greenspan. It is a ‘mystery’ to his successor Janet Yellen.

Greenspan’s conundrum dates from 2005, when he noticed that long-term Treasury bond yields fell as the Fed raised rates. (Normally, you’d expect bond yields to track interest rates higher.)

Ms Yellen’s mystery is of more recent vintage.

Last month, she wondered why inflation didn’t rise, even though the economy had hit employment…and continued making credit available at rates lower than the rate of consumer price inflation.

Free money used to cause inflation; why not now?

Both puzzles are essentially the same question: How come the economy doesn’t respond to easy money the way it used to?

We have a hypothesis…

Value-subtracting economy

Money has no intrinsic value. It is useful only as information.

In the simplest terms, money is a score-keeping system. It tells us how much of a claim we have on the world’s goods and services.

More important, it measures inputs and outputs: Time. Resources. Skill. Innovation.


We count on honest money to tell us what things are worth — whether we’re losing money or making it…when we should buy more…or invest more…or give up and go home.

Without honest money, we are lost.

That was an important reason why the Soviet Union’s economy fell apart. The apparatchiks set prices for everything. Without a free-market system, they couldn’t depend on price discovery to tell them what things were worth.

After a while, they had no idea whether they were going or coming.

By the time they gave up, the economy was taking raw materials, adding labour, time, skill, capital, and all the other ingredients it takes to make a finished product.

But the resulting output was worth less than the inputs that went into them. The Soviets had created a value-subtracting economy. The harder people worked, the poorer they got.

Fraudulent money

The US has not reached that level. But it’s headed in that direction.

The economy is running at about one-half to one-third of the rate of growth during the 1960s and 1970s.

And if consumer price inflation was calculated the way it was during the Reagan years, it would show that ‘real’ (inflation-adjusted) GDP growth has been about zero for the overall economy.

And by our estimation, more than half the country has been in a depression for the entire 21st century.

The reason is essentially the same as in the Soviet Union: Price information has become dishonest and unreliable.

The new money system — introduced in 1971 — is fundamentally fraudulent. The new dollar is not connected to gold or any other natural thing.

It is not connected to real wealth. Or real output. Or time. Or anything else that is anchored by the real world.

Out of whack

In the first 17 years of the 21st century, global central banks fed $20 trillion of new money into the system; government deficits were running wild all over the planet.

And yet…where were the higher rates? Where were the higher prices?

Where were the price signals — for credit or consumer items — to tell us that something was out of whack?

Before the 1970s — when the dollar was still anchored to gold — savings were limited. You could only save money if you first earned it. Savings reflected the wealth savers had saved.

When the government borrowed, it had to draw from this same pool of savings as everyone else.

If it borrowed too much, it ‘crowded out’ private borrowers. This drove up interest rates and could send the economy into a recession.

This, in turn, reduced federal tax receipts and increased the cost of federal debt, as the old loans needed to be rolled over at higher rates.

The limit on available savings naturally prevented federal borrowing from getting out of control.

Come the Reagan team, and it was a new world. Deficits didn’t matter because the new dollar was, essentially, unlimited.

The feds could borrow as much as they wanted without driving up interest rates. No higher rates, no recession. No recession, no need to tighten up or pull back.

But there was no inflation either.


Ms Yellen says it is a ‘mystery’. Tomorrow…the mystery solved.


Bill Bonner,
For Markets & Money

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America’s most respected authorities. Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind Markets and Money.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Markets & Money