No Time For Real Thinking in a Radical Share Market

Somebody had better tell Angela Merkel the story of Franz Ferdinand. The Archduke of Austria was assassinated on June 28th, 1914 – nearly 98 years ago to the day – in Sarajevo by a 19 year old Serbian named Gavrilo Princip. Europe, already a political tinderbox, fell headlong into the Great War.

Surely Merkel knows this history as well as anyone. But we couldn’t help thinking of the anecdote when we read her comment this morning. She replied to a seven page document by European Council President Herman von Rompuy which, among other things, argued for a Eurozone Treasury that would issue common debt. This proposal is backed by France, Italy, and Spain.

Merkel’s reply was, ‘I don’t see total debt liability as long as I live.’

Hmm. Only the German Chancellor now stands between a fiscally integrated Europe that’s able to borrow against Germany’s credit rating for ‘ever closer union’. The simple solution for centrists and Statists is to get rid of the democratically elected German Chancellor the same way they did in Greece and France. Watch out, Frau!

History and politics aside, markets are shuddering in advance of this week’s European summit. Markets, in their natural collective wisdom expressed through price, know that deleveraging is deflationary for financial asset prices. Central bank and national government rearguard actions to lower the price of credit and replace private sector demand can stave off contraction, but they can’t prevent it.

This is a brutal war of attrition in which the bankers give their friends on Wall Street covering fire to participate in risk free rallies in government bonds while shovelling the public a line of ‘bulloney’. It’s an effort to distort natural prices by lowering the cost of money. This confuses the price signals investors rely on to make their buy and sell decisions.

If you haven’t already read Slipstream Trader Murray Dawes’ take on all this, we recommend you take a few minutes out of your busy day and do so now. He’s calling it ‘Big Wednesday’. Even if you’re not a trader, it’s important to know what’s actually driving the price action of the share market, and what that price action tells you about the rest of 2012. ‘Big Wednesday’ is now live.

If you had to boil the whole letter down to one point it would probably be this: don’t underestimate the probability of unexpected events happening. Murray’s job is to trade those events, or at least have a strategy in place if they do happen. And they do happen.

But this isn’t just a matter of saying the share market is more dangerous and volatile. Everyone knows that and everyone can see it. For example, take the chart below, which was published in the September 2011 edition of the ASX publication Market Insights. If our analysis is correct, the chart shows that monetary instability in the real world is leading to price instability in the share market.

share market

The Bollinger Bands on the chart show the 50-day moving average of the ASX/200 multiplied by the standard deviation of the S&P/ASX 200 for the last 50 days. If you’re like most people, that sounds like mumbo-jumbo, but it’s actually quite simple.

In a normal world with a normal market, today’s price action is not that different from yesterday’s price action…and tomorrow’s won’t be that different from today’s. One way of expressing this statistically is through standard deviation. In a calm and normal market, daily prices don’t radically deviate from the general trend (expressed here as a 50-day moving average).

Why does the chart above look like a seismograph, then? Radical one-day swings in the share market – big variations from the average price trend – are becoming more common since the bursting of the US subprime bubble in 2007. Our argument here – and really the argument for incorporating trading analysis into your thinking – is that deleveraging coupled with high frequency trading and monetary instability makes big one day and one week price swings far more likely in the future than they have been in the past.

If we’re right about that, you’ll see more big spikes in charts like the one above. Of course, the authorities in Europe and America want to prevent those spikes. Those spikes destroy retirement wealth. They also undermine confidence in share markets.

Without being a chartist, you can tell the share market has become less stable. Maybe this is a result of economic instability. Or monetary instability. Or maybe it’s a result of the erroneous belief that more information, continuously processed by computers and brains, leads to better decision making. What this does do is leave us all constantly reacting, which leaves less and less time for real thinking.


Dan Denning
for Markets and Money

From the Archives…

The US Deficit of Deceit
2012-06-22 – Greg Canavan

How Nice to Have Friends At the Fed
2012-06-21 – Bill Bonner

Deep in the Stock Market Trenches
2012-06-20 – Murray Dawes

In Praise of the Eureka Rebellion
2012-06-19 – Dan Denning

What Could Possibly Go Wrong With Infrastructure Investment Bonds?
2012-06-18 – Dan Denning

Dan Denning
Dan Denning examines the geopolitical and economic events that can affect your investments domestically. He raises the questions you need to answer, in order to survive financially in these turbulent times.

Leave a Reply

1 Comment on "No Time For Real Thinking in a Radical Share Market"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted

World’s elite comes up with another plan to declare an asset “risk free”, and hence create yet another bubble base that turns the underlining instrument into yet another equivalent of “smoke for collateral” in order to bail themselves out short term.

The name of that “risk free” asset. Gold! … and the instruments said to be gold, and the purchase provided of the ability to falsely report their hordes of it, to commandeer physical gold from their grounds, or from their people’s at their whim.

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to