Is Oil the New Yahoo: Oil’s Run May Be Done

There’s nothing like a US$140 reality check to start your day. That’s what the oil price reached overnight in NYMEX trading. But before you go predicting US$200 by the end of the week for a barrel of crude, a quick story down the digital memory lane.

On January 4th, 2001, Yahoo stock (NASDAQ: YHOO) climbed over US$500 in intraday trading. It closed below that. But just a few months earlier one of our colleagues had speculated that YHOO was cheap at $400 and fairly valued at $500.

Yahoo was a stock everyone respected (whatever that means). It was safe to like. And it was not some start up Internet outfit. Everyone used it and everyone liked it, even if no one was sure how much advertising revenue search engines would eventually generate for shareholders.

Our colleague’s price forecast wasn’t based on any metrics that we recognised at the time. He was using what everyone else was using, eyeballs, page hits, clicks and all the buzz words that Internet companies used to justify astronomical multiples to trifling earnings (when there were earnings at all).

Yahoo shares were so in demand that the stock split 2-1 in February. A month later, the high was in for the NASDAQ at 5,048. It closed yesterday at 2,321. Yahoo has had its own troubles since then. It’s now a US$20 stock.

Is oil the new Yahoo? You can make a good argument for higher oil prices based on how tight the supply chain is. But right now, the oil price is going up on just about any little rumour. The market has ceased to be rational about it. Even oil insiders are trading predictions about how high it could be by the end of the year.

But maybe-just maybe-we saw oil put in its high for the year over-night. Mind you, we remain a long-term energy bull for those very same unfavourable supply-demand dynamics mentioned above. Based on our experience, though, this is a market that feels really toppy. Our intuition is that you could see oil put a top in sometime in the next week, if it hasn’t already happened.

Not that you want to step in front of a moving truck. Markets can remain irrational longer that you can remain solvent, the old saying goes. We’re not suggesting you bet against oil. But we are suggesting you take note of the sentiment. The bears have almost totally capitulated. The bulls are being whipped into froth. When any little thing drives the price higher, you have a very dangerous market.

Dan Denning
Markets and Money

Dan Denning
Dan Denning examines the geopolitical and economic events that can affect your investments domestically. He raises the questions you need to answer, in order to survive financially in these turbulent times.

Leave a Reply

7 Comments on "Is Oil the New Yahoo: Oil’s Run May Be Done"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Smack MacDougal
Exactly how has “The market has ceased to be rational about it.”? Folks who buy futures contracts long do so because they cannot find alternative places to bet their cash for long bets. Stock Exchange casinos seem to be crashing (less money coming in than going out) everywhere — the US, China. U.S. Treasury yields don’t pay. Oil seems to be a life-blood for an electrified, motorized world. Large-scale substitution effect has yet to materialize. The Global Glut of Money in Circulation relative to New Commerical Credit must go somewhere and it seems to be pouring into oil, foodstuffs —… Read more »

You’re probably right. I don’t see oil going much higher this year, but it could reach 200 in the next few years if the fed continues their craze monetary policy.


You have to ask the question, how much of the price increase in oil is purely because of the devaluing of the currency its priced in? If you take that away, how much has oil really increased in value? I remember a discussion pricing oil in gold and there wasn’t much of an increase, but that was several months ago.

If any small excuse will cause oil to rise, conversely will any small excuse cause the dollar to fall?


I don’t think it’s time yet to count chickens. Oil has a long way to go before prices stabilize. It’s a key resource and there ain’t enough of it to go around. $2 a liter in Australia is still cheap.

Merv Nash

You are all wrong.
There’s plenty of oil yet still to come. Saudi is only getting started to deliver their reserves:
and Canada has trillions of barrels in the Tar Sands that everybody has been screaming about.
What’s your problem? A bit of a price hike for a couple of years while Saudi and Canada raise the funds (seeing the banks are broke) to pay for the equipment to get it to market.
Have a nice day


The sea also has some new oil resources. But in the next two centuries we have to find an other alternative to oil. I think hydrogen fuel cell is best. We can not get around it!

Oil Hits New Highs… But Could Its Run Be Done?

[…] Source: Is Oil the New Yahoo: Oil’s Run May Be Done addthis_url = ‘’; addthis_title = ‘Oil+Hits+New+Highs%26%238230%3B+But+Could+Its+Run+Be+Done%3F’; addthis_pub = ”; Tags: Crude Oil Prices, Dan Denning, Investing In Oil, YHOO By Dan Denning […]

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to