Repeat After Me: Economics Is NOT a Science

On Monday and Tuesday, we visited our youngest son, Edward, a sophomore at the University of Vermont. His roommate joined us for dinner.

Okay, let me explain it to you,‘ we said.

The roommate was wondering if he should switch his major to economics.

Economics is a phony science. The more you study it, the more you think you know…and the less you really know about how an economy actually functions.

I’ll explain why in just a few sentences.

If you are a real scientist, you start with things you can know…and you can build on them.

Water boils at 212 degrees Fahrenheit at sea level, for example. The molecules heat up…then suddenly change from liquid to gas…and the pot boils. Right? Happens every time. You can count on it. And with this knowledge, you can build a steam engine.

So, the simpleminded economist comes along and says, ‘Hey, an economy is like a pot of water! You heat it up…you get more activity…and GDP grows.’

The analogy holds up superficially. You heat up the economy by putting some fire under it. If you’re a central banker, you lower interest rates. If you’re a politician, you increase the deficit.

You know there’s a risk of overheating…or causing a bubble. But you think you understand how it works. You think you can predict and control the outcome because you’re a scientist who uses mathematical models, just like a real engineer.

But the problem is you don’t know anything. You don’t know if an economy really is like water. You don’t know where sea level is. For all you know, you’re high in the Alps. And you don’t know whether the fuel you’re using adds to the fire…or subtracts from it. QE, for example, may help heat up the economy. Or it may not. No one knows for sure.

And get this. All those little molecules, you know – those individuals in the great economic pool? As soon as they catch on to what you’re doing, they will change their behaviour. That’s the big difference between water and people. Water does the same thing no matter what you say or what you think. People don’t.

We talk about the economy being like water. Well, try to imagine the contrary. Imagine water as though it was like a real economy. Imagine that the water knew you were going to bring it to a boil. Then instead of turning into vapour at 212 degrees, it might boil at 100 degrees or 170 degrees or 50 degrees in anticipation.

And then, after you’ve brought it to a boil a few times, the water gets sick of being manipulated like this…and it boils off if it even suspects you’re thinking of warming it up.

The kid started to fidget and look away. He was afraid he had run into some cranky old nut job who was going to keep talking until morning.

Well, I guess I’ll stick with engineering.

Good idea.


Bill Bonner

Join Markets and Money on Google+

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America’s most respected authorities. Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind Markets and Money.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Markets & Money