Stock Market Collapse Can Be Explained By Panicked Forced Selling

Much of the recent stock market collapse can be explained by panicked forced selling, rather than fundamentals. Sure, we’re going to have a long, deep recession – especially in certain sectors of the economy. But you must also keep in mind that stocks are denominated in paper money. Central banks and governments are fighting this credit crunch with the greatest wave of inflation in history. I’m betting they’ll succeed, albeit with many consequences.

During the panic, I read many misleading statements about stock valuation. From day to day, stocks are, obviously, worth whatever the potential buyer is willing to pay. In panics, sellers overwhelm buyers.

But over time – in normally functioning markets – a stock’s price will reflect its ability to deliver free cash flow to shareholders. The next two or three years of earnings are only a small fraction of any stock’s value.

Yet many great companies, including National Oilwell Varco, quickly crashed by 70% or 80%, just because earnings might temporarily slow. NOV’s real value did not fall that much. This was an emotional overreaction, so we took advantage and picked up some cheap call options.

The value of any company depends on factors like future sales growth, profit margins, and capital investments necessary to sustain its business. In short, the value of companies, or stocks, doesn’t really change very quickly from week to week.

But the market can change its expectations very quickly, especially when fear overwhelms rationality.

Michael Mauboussin, chief investment strategist at Legg Mason Capital Management, recently described how fear and stress can impact the stock market:

“The whole story of how humans deal with stress is really interesting, but there’s one facet worth emphasizing. When people get stressed, they tend to dramatically shorten their time horizons. If you’re a zebra being pursued by a lion, turning off systems for digestion, reproduction, immunity, and growth makes all the sense in the world because the chase will be done, or you will be done, in short order. But humans, who have many of the same physiological responses, are not dealing with a short-term threat, but rather a long-term system called the stock market. So taking a long-term view is absolutely crucial, although really hard.”

Most investors have clearly been acting under dramatically shortened time horizons. Redemption requests and margin calls have forced many fund managers to sell what they don’t want to sell at ridiculously low prices. But it finally seems we are heading back into a normally functioning market – where investors can make informed decisions without so much fear and stress.

A more orderly stock market will give us plenty of attractive short ideas. I’ll be looking for situations in which the market has already priced in a rosy scenario for a stock. We can all become better investors by honing our abilities to distinguish between the trading noise and the investing signal. In other words: What really matters to the value of this company, and what does not?

It’s amazing how often the market projects the fundamentals of the past year into the infinite future. Those who invested in bank stocks two years ago have discovered the hazard of investing on the assumption that the future will look just like the past. The same goes for traders that chase the latest hot stock up to the stratosphere, to the point where it must keep growing earnings at 30% per year for a decade to justify its valuation. Once there’s a hint that growth will fall short of expectations, formerly “hot” stocks can crash 30% or 40% in a day – especially if earnings were never sustainable to begin with.

In times of panic, the market tends to project the past year’s negative fundamentals into the future. For example, how much does the fact that U.S. gasoline demand is down 4% year over year matter to the value of oil stocks? It matters if gasoline demand keeps falling at a 4% annual rate over the next decade.

But you probably agree that this has little chance of happening, since oil consumption generally doesn’t fall quickly in response to higher prices. Yet most oil stocks now trade at valuations that anticipate an endless spiral in demand and prices.

I think the shortsighted fear about U.S. oil “demand destruction” is noise. It’s distracting investors from an important signal: sustainable worldwide demand and supply constraints that will determine the long-term price of oil. So you have the opportunity to take a contrarian stand, buy cheap oil stocks, and hold them as long as fundamentals stay intact and valuations stay reasonable.


Dan Amoss, CFA
for Markets and Money

Dan Amoss
Dan Amoss, CFA is managing editor for Strategic Investment and a contributing editor for Whiskey & Gunpowder. Dan joined Agora Financial from Investment Counselors of Maryland, investment advisor for one of the top small-cap value mutual funds over the past 15 years.

Leave a Reply

8 Comments on "Stock Market Collapse Can Be Explained By Panicked Forced Selling"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted

The sale of coles was to unlock value in the combined group, my coles shares were $15.00 and exchanged for westfarmers at $42 they are now worth $15 again. I should have cashed out. This is the worst result in my portfolio The westfarmers bit is effectively free.


Dear Sir/Madame , I was wondering if anyone can explain to me why Aussie dollar keeps going done with respect to USA dollar?. I was under impression that Australian economy is in a lot better shape than USA.


Nick: the Australian economy relies just a bit too heavily on Chinese imports of resources. Our AUD has often been called a ‘commodity currency’ (eg it goes up and down with the price of commodities, which are currently quite low).

Our economy is at the top of the slippery slope downwards. The USA has a head start on us, but you just watch us catch up.

Don’t believe what you hear from the banks and the pollies! They are doing their best to keep ‘confidence’ high. You don’t keep confidence high by being a nay-sayer.

Greg Atkinson
One reason we cannot compare the current stock market rout in Australia to previous routs is due to the impact of margin lending. In the dark days post 9/11 back in 2001 for example stocks may have taken a beating, but there was nowhere near the level of margin lending in play and thus less panicked selling. We can only hope that when confidence returns the market will rally up nicely and some of our losses recovered. As for the Australian economy I must say I am a bit of a long term bear. The Australian economy may look good… Read more »
Unpopular Truth
The AUD got smashed because all the people who do carry trades to do with the difference in interest rates between currency values, decided it was no longer a good deal. When the AU interest rate goes down, watch the AUD go down with it. Same with reverse. The currency market prices in future movement almost instantly, and they’re expecting the AU interest rate to drop another 1% next year (and have priced this in accordingly). If you want a more in depth explanation, google ‘carry trades FX’. Just don’t buy any books on the subject whatever you do. They’re… Read more »
Pat Donnelly

Fundamentally: we will all die. Try not to die without the necessities of life: adoring and grieving descendants and a long line of disappointed creditors…..
Trying to get ahead of a game that others invented and play well is a waste of the one asset we are all born with: time.
Make proper use of that and all else will fall into place!
Don’t expect any advice to make you happy. Find out what you need and satisfy that. Invest time and money in creditors and descendants….


Good point UT, thank you

AU Stock Marketing Expert
AU Stock Marketing Expert

It’s all very simple. When you panic you can’t think straight. Now you just lost.

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to