Why Tax Cuts Won’t Make Us Richer

And perhaps you’re alive

And perhaps you’re dead

Hoo ha

Hoo ha ha









– ‘Fragment of an Agon’, T.S. Eliot

We’ve always wanted to quote the lines above. But we never had the right occasion.

Perhaps this is it.

Yesterday was gloriously long. The sun rose at 5:00am. Then hour after hour of magnificent Irish summer.

We are staying in an apartment at our overseas headquarters — a converted convent close to the village of Portlaw in County Waterford.

Inside, the spaces are grand and luxurious. Outside are lawns, flowers and a field of hay, which has been baled into big, round wheels.

Crows wandered among the bales yesterday, eating whatever seeds and insects had been hiding under the hay.

St Stephen's Green, Ireland
Bill strolls through St. Stephen’s Green in Ireland
[Click to enlarge]

As afternoon turned into evening, the sun sank slowly in the sky. But it refused to go away. Hour after hour, it dipped lower. But like a shipwrecked sailor, it stayed above the surface…struggling to breathe as long as it could.

Then it was gone…and the day was over.

Say’s law

Meanwhile, back in the world of money and humbug…

Yesterday, House Speaker Paul Ryan gave voice neither to hope nor conviction, but to simple tomfoolery.

We have to get this done in 2017. Transformational tax reform can be done, and we are moving ahead. Full speed ahead.

Transformational tax reform sounds exciting. But what does it transform? And into what?

Hoo ha ha.

Let’s try to swim back in towards the shore…where we can get a toe or two into the mud and connect to the real Earth.

There is a genuine problem in America: Most people are getting poorer. We’ve never met a tax cut we didn’t like. But we’ve got news: There is no tax reform on the horizon that will make them richer.

Most people are not poor because the feds take too much of their money. They are poor because the feds have gummed up and distorted their economy.

Hobbled by regulations, fake money and crony deals, it can’t deliver the jobs and incomes people need.

This was all worked out by the classical economists. As Jean-Baptiste Say put it in 1803, in his A Treatise on Political Economy, ‘It is production which opens demand for production.

This became known as Say’s Law: Supply creates its own demand. You buy products with products. If you’re going to spend money, you have to first make something other people want to buy.

Not medical care at 10 times what it should cost. Not endless war. (Hey, we’re sending more troops to Afghanistan; that ought to get the job done!) Not dopey reports on our foreign bank accounts…or bubble stocks.

You can’t force people to buy your stuff by imposing trade barriers…or by dropping interest rates to the floor. Only win-win deals, where you earn your money, will work.

Welfare zombies

Today, we will prove one of the important points we are making: People are getting poorer.

Many of the statistics on US income and wealth are badly distorted. One major distortion comes from inflation adjustments. Official numbers tend to understate the loss of income due to the loss of buying power of the dollar.

Take an automobile, for example. A Ford pickup today is technologically superior to one from 1980. So the feds adjust the price downward. You may spend $30,000. But the feds say you only spent $15,000 because you got twice as much truck for your money.

Hey, presto! No inflation.

The other major distortion comes from averaging. Since 1980, half the population has gotten NO income gains. None.

But the top 1% has more than tripled its income and now earns 81 times more, per capita, than the people in the lower half. Average it out and it looks like everyone is better off.

Until 1990, the typical American family earned more than it needed to maintain its standard of living. Then, with post-inflation wages stagnant and consumer prices rising, it had to borrow just to stay in the same place.

This big increase in consumer credit is what kept the economy going, and living standards more or less moving ahead.

Another thing that distorts the picture is that ‘social benefits’ — such as disability, unemployment, and food stamps — are at record levels.

Never before have they contributed so much — as a percentage of disposable income — to families’ wellbeing.

This allows the feds to say that people are ‘better off’, even though they have been turned into welfare zombies.

Wealth illusion

These distortions carry over into the figures on the ‘wealth’ of American households.

According to figures from the Fed, Americans have never been richer, with $110 trillion in assets and only $15 trillion in liabilities.

But almost all the increase has come from rising real estate prices, and the phony-baloney stock and bond markets.

And this wealth, too, is concentrated in the hands of the rich. Nearly all of the wealth supposedly created by rising asset prices has gone to the top 10% of earners.

Average it out, and it looks as though we’re all better off because of the bubbles on Wall Street.

In reality, only a few people are. And they’re only better off, dare we say it, for as long as the feds can keep the bubble intact.



Bill Bonner,
For Markets & Money

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America’s most respected authorities. Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind Markets and Money.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Markets & Money