Dominance of Western Civilization Linked to Energy Consumption

One thought has been lurking around: that this whole era marks the end of an era.

At a minimum, we suspect we’re coming to the end of the credit bubble …and an end to the asset speculation bubble it wrought. We’re probably coming to the end of the Dollar Era of the world monetary system. The American empire, too, seems to be peaking out; it is squandering its resources at such a rapid pace, it is hard to see where it will get the money to expand.

“We are all freakin’ doomed.” Our friend the Mogambo puts a fine point on it . But grosso modo, it seems that we are doomed in many ways…or one big way, depending on how you look at it.

One of the themes of these Markets and Moneys for the last eight years has been what might be called the ‘topping out’ of Western Civilization. Power and money is on the move, from West to East.

“You wouldn’t believe it,” says a friend just returned from a visit to Shanghai. “The buildings…the people…it’s like a city from the future…and so incredibly big. It took my breath away.”

We feel it too…whenever we travel to the East. So many people…so much energy.

The West triumphed over the rest of the world only recently – in the 18th, 19th and 20th centuries. Before that, a person in India or China had about the same standard of living – or maybe higher – than a person in France or in Britain. But then, the West took off. What, exactly, was the source of the West’s success? No one knows. But one innovation was perhaps paramount – the West converted matter to energy…and back to matter again…at a much faster rate than ever before. In the East, only Japan was able to come even close – and not before US warships showed the island nation how far behind the curve it had fallen. Then, after a breathtaking period of imitation and growth, in the early 20th century, Japan’s military machine was able to challenge the Russians, successfully, and the Americans, unsuccessfully.

Japan’s failure in WWII was largely a matter of energy. The United States had it in abundance. Japan barely had any at all. At the crucial battle of Leyte Gulf, Japan’s ships were practically immobilised by a lack of fuel.

Yes, dear reader, our civilization…and our hegemonic power…depends on energy. A colleague sent us a chart. It shows the connection between energy and GDP. The more energy you use, the higher the standard of living. Naturally, at the very top of the living standards is the United States of America…which is also at the very top of the world in energy consumption. That it is also on top of the world in terms of military power is, perhaps, no coincidence.

We showed this chart to our intrepid correspondent, Byron King.

“Hmmm,” he said. “Looks like if there’s no energy, there’s no GDP. Correlation is not always causality. But sometimes…wow.”

Of course, it makes sense. It takes energy to make things…to move them around…to farm…to manufacture…to cook …to travel. And to carry a big stick. We remember from our brief encounter with physics that the total of energy is constant…and that energy and matter are interchangeable. Oil is black goo. It exists as matter, which we transform into energy…and use the energy to transform other things into other kinds of matter – trucks and cars, for example. Then, we put more energy into our fuel tanks to move matter around.

We have no quarrel with this program. And it salves our conscience to know that we will leave the earth no worse off – in a purely energy sense. Somehow, there has to be as much energy when we shuffle off as when we came kicking and screaming in.

The problem is not at the macro-philosophical level. The problem is a practical one. People want more stuff. It takes energy – notably in the form of that black goo we mentioned above – to make stuff. So, they’re going to want more energy to make. That is, they’re going to require more energy to raise their standards of living.

Trouble is, the supply of oil is somewhat limited. It’s not as easy to produce new oil as it is to produce new dollars. So, you can expect the price to rise. Even in real terms, the price is likely to go up, simply because more and more people want it…and the easy goo, close to the surface, in hospitable regions, has already been burnt up.

Back to the chart. While the United States, Britain, France and other rich, developed countries are at the top – both in terms of GDP/capita and energy consumption/capita – down at the bottom are countries without much stuff – but with a lot of people. China, for example. It will take a lot of energy to push China from the bottom of the chart to the top of it. But that’s exactly where China aims to go. And from what we hear, she probably will get there…which means, the Chinese have to use a lot of energy that might otherwise be used by people in the rich nations. Barring some technological breakthrough, you’d expect that people in the rich nations are going to pay a lot more for each barrel of oil they use. But current standards of living depend on oil at US$20 a barrel…maybe US$40 a barrel…maybe even US$80. At US$200 a barrel, the stuff of civilization is much more expensive…and the cost of being on top of the world is higher. The cost of being rich is going up, in other words. Ceteris paribus, that means that the rich nations aren’t going to be as rich as they used to be. It also means that the cost of operating a military machine is increasing. The American military is the biggest consumer of oil in the world.

And one other thing. There are those who think that burning fossil fuel is already much more costly than we realise. The theory is this: along with all that potential energy, locked up in the black goo, was an ocean of carbon dioxide. When you convert that matter to energy, you can’t help but release the carbon dioxide, which then floats into the atmosphere. Al Gore says that humans have never lived in a world with so much carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. The last time there was so much was millions of years ago, when it was a very different world from the one we evolved in. According to Gore, we have inadvertently recreated the conditions of the dinosaur age. And as a consequence we are going to have to live through a period of severe climate change – to which we will have to adapt, at great expense – if we can adapt at all.

Whether this is true or not, we couldn’t say. It seems believable. But so many prestigious scientists, leading statesmen and university professors believe it…the idea must be bogus in some way.

Bill Bonner
Markets and Money

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America’s most respected authorities. Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind Markets and Money.
Bill Bonner

Latest posts by Bill Bonner (see all)

Leave a Reply

5 Comments on "Dominance of Western Civilization Linked to Energy Consumption"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Coffee Addict

In any case, the black goo is far too valuable to be wasted on energy production.

Nic Meredith
Dear Bill, Love your work; I too am wary of the public spectacle. In 1996, Professor Ernst-Georg Beck of the Marion-Schule has shown that the IPCC construed and concocted the pre 1957 CO2 record from measurements on recently drilled ice cores, ignoring more than 90,000 direct measurements by chemical methods from 1857 to 1957. In a thorough review of 175 scientific papers, Professor Beck showed that today’s CO2 concentration of about 380 parts per million has been exceeded FREQUENTLY in the past, including from 1936-1944 when CO2 levels varied from 393 parts per million to 454 parts per million. The… Read more »

Agreed.Let’s relax a bit on this issue.Just breathe less and try not to pass wind.

Jose Luis Navarro

The source of western success?

1. Abandon of the mysticism thanks to Luther (who did not know the consequences of what he was doing).

2. Human return to reason, through the writing of the Greek philosophers (mainly Aristotle).

Global warming?

Because it is easier to politically dominate irrational, mystically bounded people, than rational people, politicians of all times love mysticism and irrationality. They offer them the means for unlimited of power.

Making you feeling guilty of your welfare, by using an irrational, mystical argument, such as global warming, is one of the methods.

It is interesting to consider “Peak Oil” in terms of the AGW politicised debate. I can recall in the early/mid 70’s the dire predictions of not only Global Cooling, but of the world running out of oil by 1985. We have since that time seen the former USSR rise from a net importer to an exporter of the world’s largest known reserves of oil. Is it, then, a mere coincidence that the Russian geologists and oil engineers have formulated the abiotic theory of oil, and deep drilling? Just Google “Thomas Gold”, and note the claims of scientific plagarism by the… Read more »
Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to