What the ‘Price’ is Saying About Iron Ore and Gold

Good news for stocks in the US last night, with both retail sales and employment data disappointing. Retail sales fell 0.4% in January and a revised 0.1% in December, while jobless claims unexpectedly rose too.

How is that good for stocks, you ask? It means more monetary sugar for longer. At least that is what the market is punting on. Actually, it’s what the market has solely punted on for years. All the chips are on red…or black…or whatever. It’s a bet on more asset price inflation.

Meanwhile, the world’s second largest economy is on the verge of a major credit deflation, a fact the developed markets continue to wilfully ignore. Why are they ignoring it? As we mentioned earlier this week, it appears as though ‘core’ stock markets are benefiting from safe haven capital flows as hot money exits the rapidly cooling emerging markets.

But there will be no safe haven from the looming deflation of the biggest emerging market of all – China. The world is too globalised and interconnected. The precursor to nearly all credit bubble deflations is higher interest rates, and you’re seeing that in China now.

The chart below shows the 3-month interbank rate of interest. It spiked higher in December and stayed there. This reflects the determination of The People’s Bank of China (PBoC) to get China’s credit boom under control. Whether it can actually do so is another question.

a

Higher interest rates certainly will slow things down, but it will also highlight the hundreds of billions of malinvestment made in China in recent years. You should hope the PBoC get this right. The system is too big for it to lose control.

Ambrose Evans-Pritchard, writing for the Telegraph in London, says:

‘What is clear is that we are dealing with a credit expansion of unprecedented scale, equal in size to the US and Japanese banking systems combined. The outcome may matter more for the world than anything that the US Federal Reserve does over coming months under Janet Yellen, well signalled in any case.’

But the big issue is how tighter credit in China could transmit to the rest of the world.

The transmission channel to the global banking system is through Hong Kong and Macao. Beijing’s credit squeeze is causing a scramble for off-shore dollar credit to plug the gap. It is this that keeps global regulators awake at night, for foreign currency loans to Chinese companies have jumped from $270bn to an estimated $1.1 trillion since 2009.

The Bank for International Settlements says dollar loans have been growing "very rapidly and may give rise to substantial financial stability risks", enough to send tremors across the world.

Just to be clear on how this works, attempts to slow credit growth aren’t working so far because foreign currency inflows are filling the gap. It’s thought that businesses are borrowing cheap US dollar loans via Hong Kong and ploughing the proceeds into short-term, high-yielding wealth management products.

But it’s not all bad news. Not yet anyway. Profit results in Australia have been decent so far and profits and profitability are what drives the stock market. Our only quibble is that stocks are not pricing in a skerrick of the rapidly rising and considerable risk in the economy of our largest trading partner.

Take ‘diversified’ miner Rio Tinto for example. It reported a much improved annual result, with cost cutting proving the feature. Underlying earnings hit US$10.2 billion for 2013. But it was all thanks to the iron ore division which contributed underlying earnings of US$9.86 billion.

Rio looks well priced, trading on about 10 times 2014 expected earnings. But rapidly declining iron ore prices will severely damage those expectations. It reminds us of the way the market priced the homebuilders in the US prior to housing bust.

The largest builders all traded on single-digit price earnings (PE) ratios. Were they cheap, or a value trap? Clearly they turned out to be very big value traps. If you look at the big iron ore miners today, they’ll all trading on low to single-digit PEs. Fortescue for example trades around five times 2014 expected earnings.

Value or value trap?

We think the latter, but who really knows? What we do know however is that at resource cycle peaks and troughs the market is pretty consistent at how it prices companies. For example, at the bottom of the cycle many companies will look expensive based on forward estimates because analysts are not anticipating higher future profits. They always upgrade profit expectations well after the cycle has turned.

At cycle peak, however, company’s trade on low PEs for the very same reason. Analyst profit expectations remain robust out into the future, as they don’t anticipate the cycle turn…they only follow it down.

With that in mind, consider that Australia’s largest goldminer, Newcrest, is trading on a forward PE of around 28 times, while Fortescue is on five times.

Is that the market giving you a pretty good indication of where the respective cycles are right now for iron ore and gold? We think it is.

Regards,

Greg Canavan+
for Markets and Money

Join Markets and Money on Google+

Claim your FREE Special Investor Report…

Why Interest Rates Could Stay Low for the 21st Century… and How YOU Can Profit
Markets & Money Free ReportWill Australian interest rates hit 0% in the next couple of years? If controversial economist Phillip J Anderson is correct… super–low interest rates could be here for the next century. In this special investor report you’ll learn how you can take advantage of low interest rates and potentially make a fortune over the coming decades.

Download this free report now and discover:

  • How to Boost Your Wealth Four Ways in a Low Interest Rate World: Inflation is your biggest enemy when interest rates are low. Phil reveals his four–pronged strategy to overcome this… and shows you where to profitably park your cash in the coming decades.
  • How the ‘Victorian Equilibrium’ Can Make You Rich: What if you could accurately predict where interest rates will travel in the future? You’d know the best time to lock–in rates on your mortgage repayments and save bucket loads of cash… or pick up the interest rate sensitive stocks most likely to rocket higher. As Phil reveals, if you understand the centuries old ‘Victorian Equilibrium’ discovered by an American history professor… you’ve got the next best thing to a crystal ball for interest rates.
  • Why this $402 Million Decision Signals Low Interest Rates: In October 2014, UK treasurer George Osborne announced Britain will pay back debt used to finance the First World War — 96 years after the first shot fired. Phil reveals what this landmark decision means for long term interest rates both in Australia and across the globe and how this could affect your long term investing habits.

To download your free report ‘Why Interest Rates Could Stay Low for the 21st Century’ simply subscribe to Markets and Money for FREE today. Enter your email in the box below and click ‘Send My Free Report’.

We will collect and handle your personal information in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

You can cancel your subscription at any time.

Greg Canavan

Greg Canavan is a Contributing Editor at Markets & Money and Head of Research at Port Phillip Publishing.

He advocates a counter-intuitive investment philosophy based on the old adage that ‘ignorance is bliss’.

Greg says that investing in the ‘Information Age’ means you now have all the information you need. But is it really useful? Much of it is noise, and serves to confuse rather than inform investors.

Greg Canavan

Latest posts by Greg Canavan (see all)

Leave a Reply

2 Comments on "What the ‘Price’ is Saying About Iron Ore and Gold"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
slewie the pi-rat
Guest

you mean, China isn’t just displaying some fast-as-lightning fancy kung-fu can-kicking to destroy the US Dollar, wipe out Treasuries, and establish the Yuan as the master-currency of global trade?

Justin King
Guest

Considering that the markets are backasswards and upside down, what other play is there besides gold in one form or another.
Keep it flowing, Greg.
Great stuff.

wpDiscuz
Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to letters@marketsandmoney.com.au