What We Couldn’t Say on CNBC About Economic Stimulus and Other Things

You might have seen us on TV. CNBC invited us to the Paris studio.

We sat in the room alone, with a television screen in front of us and a microphone in our ear. We wondered what they wanted to ask us.

When the question came, it puzzled us. We were not prepared for so many muddled assumptions in a single interrogatory.

‘Isn’t the world economy extremely fragile, right now?’ the interviewer led us along. ‘And don’t central banks have to deal with the problem before them, right now, and then, after the economy is more stable, they can turn their attentions to the more fundamental issues?’

The question assumes that 1) the world economy is supposed to be doing something it is not…and 2) that the central banks can make it do what they want…and 3) then, they’ll be able to do something else with it (addressing fundamental problems).

Trouble is, each assumption is wrong…delusional…or pure fantasy.

How do central banks know what the economy should be doing? Of course, they don’t. They only know what they want it to do. In the present case, they want faster rates of growth. But how can they get faster rates of growth? The question presumes that they can use “stimulus” to get it to speed up.

What, exactly, is this stimulus?

We reminded our interviewers that the original insight for economic stimulus measures came from the Bible. Pharaoh had a dream. Seven fat cows were devoured by seven lean cows. Joseph advised him to put into place a counter-cyclical economic policy. Pharaoh would save grain during the fat years… and give it out during the lean ones. This turned out to be a successful policy.

But central banks and central governments never save any grain. Fat years… lean years – they spend, spend, spend. When the lean years come they go to the granary. There’s nothing there. They have nothing to stimulate with.

So what “stimulus” were our interviewers talking about? Credit! And printing press money!

It is as if Pharaoh had not set aside grain. Instead, in the lean years, he borrowed the farmers’ seed corn. This would have given a little stimulus to the people…but then, come spring, they would have had no grain to plant…and nothing to harvest.

Similarly, the feds borrow money… taking it from private investors and thereby depriving the economy of the savings it needs to create jobs and factories. Or, going even further, it simply prints up extra money.

Imagine Pharaoh doing the same thing – putting sawdust in the granaries and pretending it was wheat! Thanks a lot!

‘Well, we’re certainly getting into the Christian allusions,’ said one interviewer. We thought we detected a snide tone. As if there is nothing in the Bible worth learning… nothing that modern, enlightened economists don’t already know.

‘They’re not Christian allusions at all,’ we thought to ourselves. ‘They’re Jewish allusions. Christ wasn’t even born until hundreds of years later.’

But we held our tongue. No point in confusing the nice young lady with history.

Then, they wanted to know about the “fiscal cliff”. Surely, something will be done to avoid a catastrophe, won’t it?

The fiscal cliff is a non-problem, we observed. It will turn out more like a ‘fiscal water slide’, we continued. ‘It will be exciting for a while… and we’ll all get soaked in the end.’

And it doesn’t make any difference who wins the White House… either. What the economy needs is real stimulus, not the phoney stimulus offered by Obama and Romney. Not the measly spending cuts. Not the timid tax increases.

Most likely, the fiscal water slide will result in very modest “cuts” and very modest tax increases. The net effect will be zero, since the feds will both take and give, probably in equal amounts.

Real economic stimulus means the feds have to stop taking so much of the nation’s resources… and stop directing them to unproductive zombie sectors. Real economic stimulus means a big cut in government spending. And big cuts in government regulations. And fewer bailouts…and subsidies…and giveaways. The zombies won’t like it.

Real economic stimulus means more money and more resources in the hands of the productive sector where they can be invested in new, productive industries.

Real stimulus means more money for the future…and less for the past.


Bill Bonner

for Markets and Money 

From the Archives…

Investment Horizons – Introducing the Hubble Market Theory
26-10-2012 – Nick Hubble

The Big Fall in the Stock Market is Still to Come
25-10-2012 – Murray Dawes

A Safer Than Super Investment?
24-10-2012 – Nick Hubble

The Lost Generation in the US Economy
23-10-2012 – Bill Bonner

NAB and Australian Banking is Oversized and Under Pressure
22-10-2012 – Dan Denning

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Best-selling investment author Bill Bonner is the founder and president of Agora Publishing, one of the world's most successful consumer newsletter companies. Owner of both Fleet Street Publications and MoneyWeek magazine in the UK, he is also author of the free daily e-mail Markets and Money.
Bill Bonner

Latest posts by Bill Bonner (see all)

Leave a Reply

2 Comments on "What We Couldn’t Say on CNBC About Economic Stimulus and Other Things"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
truth and integrity

Well put Bill.
Joseph was a fair wise and God fearing man. Pharaoh was eventually destroyed because of his depravity to mankind. We see again those who are not naturalized nationals infiltrating WASP government and excessively large financial corporations for dishonest gains. They have not the ability to seek reconciliation with truth and honesty. Consequently they are self destructive and depraved and unfortunately hurt millions of people who have turned their backs on our creator.

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to letters@dailyreckoning.com.au