Why the Government Shutdown is a Good Thing

Obama says he won’t give an inch,‘ said a French friend last night.

He had just watched the evening news.

What’s going on over there? Are they crazy?

We checked the headlines.

The Financial Times in London took an apocalyptic approach…with seductive psychological undertones: ‘America flirts with self-destruction’.

Will the flirtation go anywhere? Will this dance de l’amour lead to a full carnal embrace?

Wait a minute…

Why would not funding the federal government cause self-destruction?

Every expert warns about how dangerous this is for the economy. Every talking head on TV…every commentator…every analyst. All presume or explicitly announce that cutting off federal spending would be a BAD THING.

But why?

The stock market didn’t seem to give a damn yesterday. It rose modestly. And gold – which should be soaring as people rush to buy gold coins, bars, rifles and ammunition – instead dropped an amazing $40 an ounce.

How could this be?

Gold is what you buy when you begin to lose confidence. What could be going on? The end of the world (as we have known it) is announced and confidence actually goes up!

Let’s look at another government shutdown headline: ‘Capital Digs in for the Long Haul’, says the Wall Street Journal.

Resignation seemed to be the dominant tone in the US press.

Bloomberg looked at the matter from a couple of angles.

First, it looked at the democratic implications, noting that ‘Americans by 72% Oppose Shutdown Tied to Health Care Cuts’.

The headline leaves some ambiguity; perhaps the Americans surveyed would approve of a shutdown tied to cuts in education or defense spending.

Then Bloomberg looks at it from an economic standpoint. How much will this thing cost? It soon finds a source willing to make an estimate: ‘Shutdown to cost $300 million a day, IHS says.’

Who’s IHS? We had the same question. Bloomberg explains:

A partial shutdown of the federal government will cost the U.S. at least $300 million a day in lost economic output at the start, according to IHS Inc.

While that is a small fraction of the country’s $15.7 trillion economy, the daily impact of a shutdown is likely to accelerate if it continues as it depresses confidence and spending by businesses and consumers.

Lexington, Massachusetts-based IHS, a global market research firm, estimates that its forecast for 2.2% annualized growth in the fourth quarter will be reduced 0.2 percentage point in a weeklong shutdown.

A 21-day closing like the one in 1995-96 could cut growth by 0.9 to 1.4 percentage point, according to Guy LeBas, chief fixed income strategist at Janney Montgomery Scott LLC in Philadelphia.

"Government spending touches every aspect of the economy, and disruption of spending, more than the direct loss of income, threatens to damage investor and business confidence in ways that can seriously harm economic growth," LeBas said yesterday in an interview.

That’s it. We can’t take anymore. The economics profession has turned itself into a bunch of toadies for the politicians and world-improvers. The nonsense. The claptrap. It’s time to stand up and be counted!


Well, is there anybody else? Are we all alone?

As we explained yesterday, there are two ways to get what you want. Force and violence on the one hand. Or trade and persuasion on the other. (Somewhere in the middle is fraud. But let’s ignore that for the moment.)

An economy is built on trade and persuasion. You have to do something that others will pay you for. You make something. You offer some service.

Others do the same – offering you something that you want. One makes a pair of shoes…another brews some beer. Oh, you know how it works!

But one part of the economy doesn’t work that way. That’s the part that the US government controls. That part depends on brute force. No customer has to be satisfied.

No real want has to be addressed. No meeting of the minds between buyer and seller ever has to take place. You pay your taxes or the feds put you in jail. You do as you are told (no jokes allowed in the TSA line!) or they put you in prison.

America has changed so much,‘ continued our French friend. ‘I used to visit every summer when I was a teenager. It was a rite of passage for the French. America was so free. So different from Europe. We would go to California and hitch-hike up and down the coast. It was the 1960s. Everyone was unbelievably friendly and open. I loved it.

But I went back just this summer. It’s a different place. They treat you like a war criminal when you go through customs. And you wouldn’t think of hitch-hiking. People are still nice. But that spirit of freedom seems to have disappeared. It’s a lot more like Europe now. But with more police.

Yes, it is more like Europe, where government plays a larger role.

And now, would reducing the role of government really make people worse off?

Would less brute force in the economy really be such a disaster?

What if people only got more of what they really wanted…only what they could get by honest manufacture, trade and commerce?

What if the zombies were cut back?

Would that be so bad?


Bill Bonner
for The Daily Reckoning Australia

Join Markets and Money on Google+

From the Archives…

The Fed Does the Reverse Volcker and Targets the US Unemployment Rate
27-09-2013 – Greg Canavan

How Much Juice can Australian Property Have Left?
26-09-2013 – Greg Canavan

Nothing Lasts Forever…Especially Easy Money
25-09-2013 – Chris Mayer

The Unintended Consequences Brewing Thanks to the Federal Reserve
24-09-2013 – Greg Canavan

The Market’s Declining Response To ‘Open Mouth’ Operations
23-09-2013 – Dan Denning

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America's most respected authorities.

Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind Markets and MoneyDice Have No Memory: Big Bets & Bad Economics from Paris to the Pampas, the newest book from Bill Bonner, is the definitive compendium of Bill's daily reckonings from more than a decade: 1999-2010. 

To have Bill's reckonings delivered straight to your inbox subscribe to Markets and Money for free here.

Read more

Bill Bonner

Latest posts by Bill Bonner (see all)

Leave a Reply

5 Comments on "Why the Government Shutdown is a Good Thing"

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
slewie the pi-rat

‘…that spirit of freedom seems to have disappeared.’

well, no wonder…
we are locked in a carnal embrace w/ Boilerplate Nanny.
that damned Madonna bra!

Great Article! I was raised in the Good Ole U.S.A., but am now living in some strange book called 1984. Well, not that bad, but you should hear the jokes in the pubs, or look at the way old-timers look at police or the TSA (our customs gendermes.) Its a wonderful place…still. I recommend it. The massages by the TSA are especially tension relieving prior to a flight. I highly recommend them…and always take them rather than getting zapped by some poorly engineered XRAY machine. I live in the West Village, on the isle of Manhattan in the city of… Read more »
I always enjoy your articles, Bill. “What if people only got more of what they really wanted…only what they could get by honest manufacture, trade and commerce?” This is the clincher. For too long the western world – led by the Americans – has thought they can get something for nothing. You only become the greatest empire on the earth through hard work and self-sacrifice. And possibly luck – the British and Europe tripped over at about the same time. Those days are over, and so too is the empire if they don’t turn it around. The exact same thing… Read more »

America is broken – Has been for a long time.(Indeed, the evidence lies in the causes of the GFC) Obama is simply taking a few baby steps to try and fix it, so in due course the captains of Wall St will hand orders to their misfit Republicans to bend their ways. Vested interests, and all – they are now in Obama’s gun sights.


‘No! shut them all down’, c3po, Star Wars, and they were all saved.

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to letters@marketsandmoney.com.au