Bubble Age Jobs Lost Because of Recession

Where have all the jobs gone
long time passing
Where have all the jobs gone
long time ago
Where have all the jobs gone
Gone to graveyards everyone
When will they ever return
Oh when will they ever return

– Sung to the tune of “Where Have All the Flowers Gone?”

“Many lost jobs in US will never come back…” says The Wall Street Journal.

Need we explain why? Because they’re not lost, waiting to be rediscovered. They’re not missing in action, to be repatriated after the fighting stops. Instead, they’re dead. Gone forever.

There have been 7.2 million jobs lost since recession began. Many of these jobs were Bubble Age jobs. Millions of people, for example, earned their money in ‘housing.’ They were putting up houses in the sand states…or building granite countertops…or selling, flipping, financing the houses. Those jobs are gone forever. Never again in our lifetimes are we likely to see such an explosion in the housing industry. Sure, people will still build houses…and do all the other work involved in the traditional housing industry. But it will be only a fraction of the industry it was in the 2002-2007 period.

There were also all the jobs involved in selling things to people who didn’t need them and couldn’t afford them. Labor was needed at every step of the way – manufacturing (perhaps in China), shipping, stocking, retailing, fixing, and financing the stuff.

And don’t forget all that mall space…and all the trucks…and all the other things that supported the over-consumption of the Bubble Age.

And now the Bubble Age is over. It will not come back, no matter how much cash and credit the feds pump into the system. (Not that they can’t make things worse…in a BIGGER bubble…but that is not yet in sight.)

In The Wall Street Journal yesterday was an item about Las Vegas. The casinos are folding up their expansion plans, says the WSJ.

But the big news yesterday was that the service industries are growing again…at least that’s what the latest figures show. This news so delighted investors that they bid up Dow stocks 112 points. Oil rose above $70. Gold posted a $13 gain.

Don’t get too excited about that rise in the service sector. Everything bounces…even dead jobs. Dead jobs bounce; they still don’t get up. After months of decline, it may be true that the service industries have had a rebound, but don’t expect them to begin recovering the stamina and strength of the bubble years. A few more people may have gotten jobs serving drinks in Detroit’s bars last month, but it is not likely to turn into a durable recovery of the job market.

In the 1990s, the US economy added 2.15 million new jobs every year. It needed to add at least 1.5 million or so just to remain at full employment – that is, with about 5% of the workforce unemployed at any time.

To put that number in perspective, this year the economy as LOST 2.5 million jobs, just in the last six months. Those jobs aren’t coming back. As we keep saying, this is a depression. It is a major correction, in which the economy needs to find new jobs…because it can’t continue to do what it has been doing.

New jobs are typically created by new businesses – small businesses that are growing. Big businesses already have all the market share they’re going to get. They also typically have all the employees they need. Then, when hard times come, they discover that they don’t need all that they have, so they cut back.

Job cuts from large businesses is what you expect in a recession. But this time it is different. This time, big businesses have let people go by the million. But small business has not been hiring them either. So not only is unemployment growing…the trend shows no signs of coming to an end.

Economists are reconciled to high unemployment levels for a long time. The head of the IMF says unemployment might peak out in 8 to 12 months. Even if that were true, it will be a very long time before the job market recovers. Just do the math.

We’ll keep it simple. The economy needs, say, 1.5 million new jobs per year. Instead, over the last two years, it lost 7.5 million. Now, it has to stop losing jobs…let’s just say that happens a year from now. By then, the total of jobs lost may be near 10 million. Plus, there are the new jobs it needed – but never got – over that 3 year period. That’s another 4.5 million. So, the total will be about 14.5 million jobs down. Then, let us say, because we are in a generous and optimistic mood, that the economy then begins creating jobs again…at the rate it did during the ’90s. What ho! After five years, that still leaves the economy more than 10 million jobs short, doesn’t it?

In order to get back to full employment, the economy has to surprise us on the upside. It has not merely to return to the growth levels of the ’90s…it has to surpass them. It needs to grow so fast it creates 3 million jobs per year. And even then, it would take nearly 10 years to get back to full employment.

Pretty grim, huh?

Well, don’t worry about it. It won’t be like that. It will be worse.

“Uh…Bill…what do you mean, ‘worse’?”

Glad you asked.

In the typical post-war recession, jobs are lost…then they are recovered when the economy gets on its feet again. But this happened in the credit expansion of the ’45-’07 period. Each recession was just a pause, when the economy was catching its breath. Then, it was off again…in the same direction – up the mountain of credit.

This time, it’s not a typical post-war recession. It’s something different. Now, we’ve reached the peak. We’re coming down the other side…wheee! Look out below!

Now we don’t need all those people building houses, stocking the shelves and selling things. We don’t need such a big financial industry either. Now, people want to get rid of credit, not get more.

And the businesses that were goosed up in the credit bubble are now deflating fast. They’re not just taking a break. They’re lining up the jobs and shooting them in the back of the head. Those jobs are gone. (See below…)

In a ‘normal’ recession, jobs reappear because the economy continues in the same direction. In a depression, it changes course. Debts are paid off. Spending goes down, more or less permanently. The economy actually contracts…until consumer debt is once again down at an acceptable level…or a new model for growth can be found.

The Wall Street Journal mentions a statistician who was making $100,000 a year. He too is a victim of depression. His job has been outsourced to India. Businesses, with less revenue coming in the door, must cut costs in whatever way they can. Labor is the single biggest item on most firms’ ledgers. They will reduce it however they can. And once the change is made, there is little chance that the job will come back.

It is a little like a battle. In an attack, troops often get separated. They are ‘lost’ – for a while. Then, the winning side is able to recover its missing troops as it advances. But the losing side gives up its troops forever. They are stuck behind enemy lines and cannot rejoin their units.

We are now on the losing side of a credit battle. Having gained so much ground, and so many jobs, in the advance, the United States is now giving them up.

“I expect over the next several months, mainstream pundits and forecasters will start worrying about tepid hiring, even as the pace of job losses slows,” Strategic Short Report’s Dan Amoss chimes in. “As we ‘lap’ the 2009 corporate cost cutting by early 2010, and top lines fail to rebound, earnings estimates will have to come back down. I’m amazed at how many sell-side analysts are modeling V-shaped recoveries in 2010 earnings. Most stock prices are disconnected from reality.”

And here is a story we foretold years ago. Private equity was mostly a fraud, we said. Sharp operators bought companies for more than they were worth, loaded them with debt, collected huge fees, and then sold them back to the public or to other private equity firms. Come the revolution, we mused, these deals would go bad.

Well, the revolution has come. The deals have gone bad. The New York Times reports:

“Simmons [the mattress company] says it will soon file for bankruptcy protection, as part of an agreement by its current owners to sell the company – the seventh time it has been sold in a little more than two decades – all after being owned for short periods by a parade of different investment groups, known as private equity firms, which try to buy undervalued companies, mostly with borrowed money.

“For many of the company’s investors, the sale will be a disaster. Its bondholders alone stand to lose more than $575 million. The company’s downfall has also devastated employees like Noble Rogers, who worked for 22 years at Simmons, most of that time at a factory outside Atlanta. He is one of 1,000 employees – more than one-quarter of the work force – laid off last year.

“But Thomas H. Lee Partners of Boston has not only escaped unscathed, it has made a profit. The investment firm, which bought Simmons in 2003, has pocketed around $77 million in profit, even as the company’s fortunes have declined. THL collected hundreds of millions of dollars from the company in the form of special dividends. It also paid itself millions more in fees, first for buying the company, then for helping run it. Last year, the firm even gave itself a small raise.

“Wall Street investment banks also cashed in. They collected millions for helping to arrange the takeovers and for selling the bonds that made those deals possible. All told, the various private equity owners have made around $750 million in profits from Simmons over the years.”

Until tomorrow,

Bill Bonner
for Markets and Money

Bill Bonner

Bill Bonner

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America’s most respected authorities. Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind Markets and Money.
Bill Bonner

Latest posts by Bill Bonner (see all)

Leave a Reply

7 Comments on "Bubble Age Jobs Lost Because of Recession"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Richo (the Second)

Good article – very insightful – perhaps our politicians should be more aware of this! I note an airline in the UK today shed 1,000 jobs.

Whirling Dervish
Great article Bill, Yes its certainly going to be bad. They are kidding themselves if they think a generation of growth due to unprecedented debt levels is going to be corrected after a couple of negative quarters. The worst thing is this happened on a global scale. The entire global economy will need to shrink as it purges itself of the demand caused by debt. Here in Australia we are waving the flag of victory and sounding the all clear as the enemy planes are still flying overhead and bombs are still falling and exploding on the ground. My only… Read more »
This is what happened during the great depression! 27/3/1931. Premier Lang says NSW unable to pay interest due to British bondholders. 22/4/1931. State Savings Bank closes its doors following a rush of heavy withdrawals. 26/5/1931. Victoria has 35900 unemployed in city & 16000 in country. 2/6/1931. Premier’s conference in Melbourne agrees to cut salaries, wages & pensions. 27/7/1931. UK jobless figure reaches record 2.71 million. 6/8/1931. NSW State Treasury says it has no money to pay public servants salaries. 7/9/1931. The King decides to take pay cut of 50000 pounds a year while economic crisis lasts. 10/9/1931. Melbourne police wielding… Read more »

I said a long time ago (not on these comments boards) that people need to adopt a new paradigm (god I hate that word) of full employment being 90%. Not the 95% governments around the world currently target.

Absolute proof of the criminality of the system. The ethos of capitalist greed: Where anyone with a sense of integrity, work ethic, and fair play cannot succeed. This is all made possible by a belief in the legitimacy of paper debt as a form of money. It has enabled complete control over all media, politicians, and most humans world wide. Generally Speaking: In reality there are only six forms of currency: Gold, Guns, Gas, Food, Sex, and Drugs. Notice how they are all controlled. How about we just all return to some common sense? Like maybe Gold and Silver are… Read more »
Biker Pete, Vancouver Island, Canada
Biker Pete, Vancouver Island, Canada

Well, there’s a Lite Manifesto for ya! (Don’t know if will fly…!) :)

Earl Mardle

No need to write new lyrics, Springsteen got there first, 25 years ago.

My Home Town.

Now Main Street’s whitewashed windows and vacant stores
Seems like there ain’t nobody wants to come down here no more
They’re closing down the textile mill across the railroad tracks
Foreman says these jobs are going boys and they ain’t coming back to your hometown

Amazing how a rock singer could see it coming but the wide boys on Wall St missed it completely.

Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to letters@marketsandmoney.com.au