Gas Land Rush Continues

–Your editor missed all the excitement last week. He was up on the rainy Sunshine Coast to follow up on the shale gas story told in Revolution in the Desert. And some of the very events discussed in that report began to gather pace over the last few days. Today’s Daily Reckoning will tell you what it means for energy and precious metals stocks.

–Let’s start with energy. BHP’s $14.1 billion bid for US shale-gas play Petrohawk Energy is obviously the big news of the last few days. What does it mean? Let’s break it down three ways: what it means for BHP, what it means for shale gas, and what it means for the shale gas industry in Australia.

–For BHP shareholders the question is whether BHP is right about the direction of gas prices. BHP is basically making a bet on higher gas prices. Analysts in Australia have rubbished the deal (on a short-term basis) because they believe BHP can generate higher returns on assets like iron ore and coal.

–From BHP’s perspective, there are only two counter arguments. One: under Marius Kloppers the company is making a bad deal for the sake of a doing any deal. Better to look busy that just do another boring old share buyback. That’s one explanation.

–The other explanation is that Kloppers thinks this is the bottom for natural gas. There haven’t been too many commodities trading near bargain prices. But natural gas is one of them. The huge supply boom/glut from US shale is part of the reason. A bet on gas now is a bet on higher demand.

–It’s also a bet on gas becoming more important in the world’s energy mix. That seems like a given, and not just because it’s the main conclusion we draw in Revolution in the Desert. It seems like a given because gas is the most logical and likely replacement for coal as the fuel for new power plants. Australia’s own carbon tax favours gas to the extent that it will lead to the phase out of coal-fired power stations.

–There is also the issue of depletion in conventional oil fields. One of the real eye openers from our trip to the Offshore Technology Conference in Houston is how expensive it’s going to be finding and producing the next trillion barrels of oil. They’re out there. But they’re in remote and hostile places.

–If shale gas reserves are developed in the countries that are thought to have them, it will mark a shift from an oil-dominated global energy market to…whatever comes next. If you want to know what comes next…or at least what we think comes next…watch Revolution in the Desert.

–Is BHP overpaying for Petrohawk? Petrohawk has 3.4 trillion cubic feet of proved natural gas equivalent reserves (Tcfe). It has a resource base of 35 Tcfe. Prior to BHP’s offer—which Petrohawk has embraced—the company said it expected to produce 950 million cubic feet of gas a day this year, with liquids accounting for 15 per cent of output.

–Remember BHP spent $4.5 billion on the Fayetteville shale assets of Chesapeake Energy earlier this year. When you add up its existing oil and gas production with its new US acreage, BHP is on pace to produce a million barrels of oil equivalent a day in five years. That’s a lot of oil for a mining company.

–But obviously BHP has seen the projection that shale gas will make up one-half of US total gas production by 2020. Low prices generate demand. And BHP seems more than happy to cop the short-term negative analyst coverage in order to make a long-term bet that when gas prices are higher, the return on its new assets will look a lot more attractive to shareholders.

–We’ll ask our valuation expert Greg Canavan what he thinks. And we’ll see if our resident in-house trader Murray Dawes sees anything in the BHP chart you should know about. But our main observation is that BHP has put itself in position to be the world’s 7th largest oil and gas company based on its total resources.

–This is clearly a bet on energy commodities having a lot more growth potential than bulk commodities, like iron ore and coal. Is it the right bet? We’ll see. The other important question is whether BHP shares are a good bargain.

–BHP paid a 61% premium for Petrohawk’s shares, based on a 20-day average of its share price. You only do that sort of thing when you believe in the long-term case for buying energy assets when they’re cheap. It’s really a bet on energy and gas. And it also echoes the Accelerated Transformation Program of Saudi Aramco that we spoke about in Revolution in the Desert. When you have world-class companies shifting their strategic focus to accommodate a new set of facts on the ground, you should find out what those facts are.

–By the way, developments on the ground here in Australia are already heating up in the shale gas space. We’ll write more about that tomorrow. But BHP would certainly hope to learn a lot about producing shale gas in the States. It is knowledge that could come in very handy in developing Australia’s shale gas assets, of which there are many.

–Now, what about the precious metals? Moody’s put US government debt on review for a potential downgrade at the end of last week. This was no surprise. But Comex August gold traded at US$1599.20 this morning. It’s a bit lower as we write. But you can see the obvious connection. Gold makes new highs as debt problems metastasize.

–You can be pretty sure that there’s going to be some kind of bogus deal between President Obama and the Congress before August 2nd. That’s the artificial deadline US Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner has set for Congress to lift the statutory debt ceiling. But all of that is posturing and theatrics.

–The gold price is moving again because investors know the bankers and the politicians are lying, stupid or some combination of both. Sovereign debt problems in Europe and America are paper money problems. And gold is not paper money.

–Gold at record highs is not cheap. But it’s probably going to go much higher before all is said and done. That said, it is always desirable to buy quality assets on weakness. Diggers and Drillers boss-man Dr. Alex Cowie took advantage of the weakness in silver to make two new recommendations. If you want to read about his case for the metal, you can do so here.

–Alex, like anyone who owns silver bullion or stocks, was disappointed with silver’s big correction down from $50. But not surprised. And not worried either. His long-term target for silver is much, much higher. And his argument for that target is based on an understanding of silver as money…and the supply/demand dynamics unique to the silver market.


Dan Denning
Markets and Money Australia

Dan Denning
Dan Denning examines the geopolitical and economic events that can affect your investments domestically. He raises the questions you need to answer, in order to survive financially in these turbulent times.

Leave a Reply

3 Comments on "Gas Land Rush Continues"

Notify of
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted

One day the PM shares are going to finish beating around the bush and become the greatest mega bubble ever. Patience.

A gas bubble looks likely too ;)

Comment by Lachlan on 18 July 2011: One day the PM shares are going to finish beating around the bush and become the greatest mega bubble ever. Patience. A gas bubble looks likely too ;) Yes, I agree Lachlan.. BOW were a buy for me a little over a month ago.. Low 80’s Happy with that :) Gold miners are waiting for a nudge… My speculative Bolivian play is tempting me to buy more… Have to resist the urge to overextend on such a speculative play.. Potential: I really think it has the scope to be the elusive 10 bagger… Read more »
Seems like NZ inflation works for the 4 pillars balance sheets, the CDS holds with smoke collateral, APRA, and the RBA even if it doesn’t for the NZ people. Nearly ready to close out …. maybe 1.24, we’ll see. The US taxpayer is investing in a new build brown coal plant in that western tinpot narco gangster state and slav influence denier of a place called Kosovo. Pretender greenies in the EU are applauding as they close out their nuke plants and the Germans are even before this still firing 24% on brown coal as they tell us to shut… Read more »
Letters will be edited for clarity, punctuation, spelling and length. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be posted. We will not post all comments.
If you would prefer to email the editor, you can do so by sending an email to