The West Sowed the Seeds of the Paris Attacks

‘They that sow the wind, shall reap the whirlwind.’

Hosea, 8-7

We drove back into Paris last night…

France is still in a state of emergency. A police blockade near Dreux stopped cars headed out of the city.

There were about 20 gendarmes manning the barrier, some armed with machine guns.

Police shined flashlights into passing cars, pulling over those they wanted to inspect more closely.

A city on edge

This morning, in our favourite café at the foot of Rue Poussin, in the 16th arrondissement, everyone drinks his coffee and eats his croissant while watching the big TV screen in the corner.

‘A kamikaze woman has been killed,’ is the headline story.

‘Assault still going on…’ says a subhead.

‘Explosions rock St. Denis,’ adds another.

St. Denis, a northern suburb of Paris, has been shut down. People who work in the area are told not to go to their jobs. Buses aren’t running. The streets are blocked by hundreds of police.

‘Two terrorists killed,’ says the latest headline…

Paris is on edge. Since France began bombing Islamic State (ISIS) strongholds in Syria, the group has targeted the city for special treatment, say the papers.

About 700 French citizens or residents have joined ISIS to fight in Syria — the largest number of any European country. That means ‘Daesh’ (pronounced ‘dash’ — the new…and apparently derogatory…name that political leaders are using for ISIS) has the potential manpower to carry out attacks.

Nothing but trouble

Our beat is economics…money…and finance. Not politics. But they intertwine, like poison ivy around a grapevine. One produces edible fruit; the other makes you itch.

We have wondered, for example, why the Fed would continue with policies that seem to benefit only a slim part of the population while being harmful to everyone else.

Is it politics? Or economics?

We might wonder the same thing about foreign policy: why would the US undertake an expensive program of sowing gusts all over the windblown Middle East?

After the US helped al-Qaeda get off the ground, many analysts hold the country responsible for creating ISIS. And for bestowing on the group — by criminal incompetence, if not knowledgeable forethought — its leadership and almost all its serious weapons.

Why would it do such a thing?

The typical American or Frenchman stands to gain nothing but trouble from these policies — meddling in the economy and in the Middle East.

There is no evidence of any positive outcome — neither in the past nor the future. But they continue.

Why? Could it be that they are not just mistakes? Could it be that they are actually intended to create the grotesqueries we see today?

We’ll come back to this question in a minute. First, we note that there was almost no movement in the major stock market indexes yesterday.

The world is slowing

The news continued to reinforce our view: the world economy is slowing.

Industrial output in the US continues to creep upward. But the rate of growth has slowed eight out of 10 months this year.

India’s exports were down for 11 months in a row in October…following China and Brazil on the path to a slump.

And the price of steel has fallen 55% since its 2011 high.

Like oil, steel is a key ingredient in a modern economy. Almost anything you want to make is going to take at least a little steel. The falling price reflects a lack of orders…which reflects a slowing world economy.

It also shows what happens when central banks rig up an economy.

Their zero-interest-rate policies caused a boom, which led manufacturers to overestimate demand…and induced them to borrow money at low rates to increase capacity…which led to an increase in steel production.

The increased supply led to a bust when real demand turned out to be less than projected.

At the Diary, we don’t want a higher rate of interest. Or a lower rate. We only want a ‘true rate.’

‘Untrue rates’ come from central bank-caused miscalculations. This has ended up in a mismatch between buyers and users of steel — causing confusion, malinvestment, and a misuse of resources.

So why would central banks — allegedly run by serious economists — do such a thing? Why would they make such obvious mistakes?

Which takes us back to where we began today…

Busts, bubbles, and blow-ups

Our comments on massacres were little appreciated by readers.

One reader, a Vietnam vet, said we shouldn’t bring up the My Lai Massacre — in which US soldiers killed 350 Vietnamese people during the Vietnam War — in the context of the recent Paris attacks.

And some of our Roman Catholic readers would have preferred that we forgot the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre, in which Catholic mobs killed thousands of French Protestants.

We also brought up two Second World War massacres by German and Soviet troops. But Nazis and Communists — if there are any among our dear readers — held their peace.

Our critics may be right: Maybe comparisons really are odious. But our point was just that the perps of the Paris massacre shouldn’t feel so special: No one has a monopoly on butchery. When the conditions are right, any group could go at it.

So, why sow the wind? Why would either Paris or Washington enter an unwinnable, unfathomable war…sure to be punctuated by episodes of mass murder?

And why would their central banks and central governments push financial policies that cause booms, busts, bubbles, and blow-ups, benefiting the few rather than the many?


Bill Bonner,
For Markets and Money, Australia

From the Archives…

Does Working 1 Hour a Week Equal Employment?
By Vern Gowdie | Nov 14, 2015

The Chinese Consumer Boom Is Still To Come
By Shae Russell | Nov 13, 2015

Why Bogan Pride is Destroying Your Investments
By Shae Russell | Nov 12, 2015

Is a Share Market Recovery Just Around the Corner?
By Vern Gowdie | Nov 11, 2015

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America’s most respected authorities. Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind Markets and Money.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Markets & Money