Why Federal Reserve Policies Are Dangerous Claptrap

We promised to take up an important theme. True to our word, we will do so.

The subject is wages. And we are digging in. On the surface, we lament the lack of any forward progress in US hourly compensation over the last half century.

Deeper down, in the clay and subsoil, we wonder how it is possible that the world’s richest and most technologically advanced economy ever, operating during a 50-year period that included the invention of the Internet…the triumph of capitalism in China and Russia…and a landing on the moon — that is the most bountiful half-century in human history — failed to make its most important component parts better off.

And at the bedrock level, we find the explanation: Fed policies are dangerous claptrap.

Quackery and incompetence

Yesterday, we described and illustrated the quackery and incompetence behind the US Federal Reserve’s economic forecasts. Clearly, it never knows what is coming. Today, we show what its policies have wrought.

Let’s begin with a conclusion: Thomas Piketty is wrong about the way the world works. He sees the working man…and the investing man…competing for the material rewards of a capitalist society.

As an old-fashioned lefty, he presumes the man with overalls will always get the short end of the stick. The working man has only the time on his hands and the sweat on his brow to offer his employer. Generation after generation, he has no more time or sweat than he had in the time of Jacob and Ishmael.

Capital, on the other hand, compounds…year after year…growing larger by the day…with more and larger factories.. darker and more satanic mills.

Piketty even gives a number — on page 356 of his tome — for the rate at which capital annually compounds: 4.5%.

As Jim Grant of Grant’s Interest Rate Observer helpfully points out, this is mathematically absurd. If wealth had compounded at that rate from the time of Christ until today, we would all be bazillionaires. Instead, capital compounds…and then gets whacked by bear markets, depressions, wars, and central bank policies.

In fact, there is no competition between capital and labor. Both benefit, according to relative scarcity and abundance of what they have to offer, from each other’s contributions.

Cheating the working man

The capitalist puts up the resources. The working man turns them into something worth more — thanks to the value of his own time — than the resources he had to work with.

The richer the capitalist, the more pairs of skillful hands he needs to help him fructify his wealth. And the more the laborer has to work with — a backhoe, for example, rather than a shovel — the more new wealth he can create.

Generally, capitalists and laborers get wealthier, or poorer, together. When they don’t, something is wrong.

Readers of these pages already know what: The cronies always use the police power of government to cheat the working man, stifle competition, prevent progress…and generally strangle the public welfare with red tape, taxes, and regulation.

In the event, they have managed to keep wages more or less unchanged for 46 years.

On this issue, we quote our favorite ex-White House budget director, David Stockman:

Real hourly earnings of production workers at about $20.50 per hour in May were exactly the same as they were when President Lyndon Johnson was hauling his hunting dogs around by their ears back in 1968.

[M]onetary inflation seemed to work for a few years because in those times of trade account surpluses organized labor was able to push up wage rates faster than the CPI – so real wages reached an all-time record of $22.30 per hour in the early 1970s.

Ironically, the catalysts for that final wage push were soaring construction wages in NYC obtained by the building unions working on the World Trade Center, and a 70-day strike at GM which resulted in the bountiful UAW "pattern agreement" that ultimately took Detroit down.

More importantly, the surge of Fed-fueled inflation in the late 1960s also took down the monetary system and paved the way for today’s destructive monetary central planning which erodes main street living standards and gifts the 1% with speculative windfalls on financial assets.

Specifically, the CPI had averaged about 1.2% annually between 1953 and 1965, but then soared to upwards of 6% by 1970-1971 (a level never seen outside of the two world wars and post-war demobilizations after the Fed’s opening in 1914).

Amazing, isn’t it?

That is, in a period of apparent unrivaled progress, somehow the most important measure of economic success — the value of the working man’s time — went nowhere.

Short end of the stick? He got no part of the stick at all.


What went wrong?

Nasty capitalist cheating? Or Federal Reserve policies?


Bill Bonner
for The Markets and Money Australia

From the Archives…

The Children of a Long Inflation
21-6-2014 – Callum Newman

Join Markets and Money on Google+

Since founding Agora Inc. in 1979, Bill Bonner has found success and garnered camaraderie in numerous communities and industries. A man of many talents, his entrepreneurial savvy, unique writings, philanthropic undertakings, and preservationist activities have all been recognized and awarded by some of America’s most respected authorities. Along with Addison Wiggin, his friend and colleague, Bill has written two New York Times best-selling books, Financial Reckoning Day and Empire of Debt. Both works have been critically acclaimed internationally. With political journalist Lila Rajiva, he wrote his third New York Times best-selling book, Mobs, Messiahs and Markets, which offers concrete advice on how to avoid the public spectacle of modern finance. Since 1999, Bill has been a daily contributor and the driving force behind Markets and Money.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Markets & Money